Jump to content

Croatian Wikipedia

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Bukowski112 (talk | contribs) at 07:13, 4 September 2018 (Undid revision 857774103 by Shellwood (talk)). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Favicon of Wikipedia Croatian Wikipedia
Croatian Wikipedia's Main Page on March 19, 2017
Type of site
Internet encyclopedia project
Available inCroatian
OwnerWikimedia Foundation
URLhr.wikipedia.org Edit this at Wikidata
CommercialNo
RegistrationOptional

The Croatian Wikipedia (Croatian: Wikipedija na hrvatskome jeziku) is the Croatian version of Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, started on February 16, 2003.[1] This version has 223,053 articles and a total of 7.04 million edits have been made (live count). It has 320,367 registered user accounts, out of which 462 are active (defined as having performed an action on Wikipedia in the last 30 days), and the number of administrators is 14.

In late 2013, the Croatian Wikipedia received attention from international media for promoting a fascist worldview as well as bias against Serbs of Croatia and anti-LGBT propaganda by the means of historical revisionism and by negating or diluting the severity of crimes committed by the Ustaše regime.

Throughout 2014, fewer than two dozen editors made more than 100 edits a month; around 150 made more than 5 edits a month.[2] Over 600 articles are ranked as featured (Croatian: Izabrani članci).[3]

2011 reliability analysis

In a study by Kubelka and Šoštarić from 2011, the reliability of the Croatian Wikipedia was compared to the Croatian Encyclopedia - the Croatian national encyclopedia.[4] Twenty-four reviewers, experts in specific fields, analyzed a representative selection of articles according to the parameters of informativeness, accuracy of presented information, sufficiency, direction and objectivity. Articles were analyzed in 11 thematic categories: arts and culture; history and biographies; medicine and health; technology and applied science; geography; religion; science; mathematics and logic; philosophy; sport and society; and social sciences. Articles were sorted into categories using machine learning techniques, and feature weight statistics were calculated using tf–idf. A total of 500 articles in 250 pairs were randomly chosen and sorted into categories to serve as representative samples.[5]

In both samples facts were manually enumerated - 3015 from the Croatian Encyclopedia and 3315 from Croatian Wikipedia. Comparison for factual accuracy showed that for every error in the Croatian Encyclopedia 2.25 errors were found in Croatian Wikipedia.[6] Analysis by individual categories showed that most errors in Croatian Wikipedia were in the philosophy category, where on average two errors in ten articles were found. The only category where the Croatian Encyclopedia had more errors was natural sciences, where the ratio was 1.25:0.75 in favor of Croatian Wikipedia.[7] Of those factual errors, the ratio was 21:12 for major errors, and 34:23 for minor errors. The overall ratio for minor factual errors was thus lower, the only exception being the society and social sciences category, where the minor error ratio was 3:1.

The reliability analysis for Croatian Wikipedia indicated that 74% of articles were error-free, and 11% had minor errors. Major factual errors were found in 5% of articles, while 4% of articles had both major and minor errors. Overall 85% of articles were deemed "satisfactory" (error-free and containing minor errors), while in comparison 92% of articles in the Croatian Encyclopedia achieved the same rating.[8] Forty percent of articles in Croatian Wikipedia were assessed as sufficiently informative, as opposed to sixty-two percent of articles in the Croatian Encyclopedia. Sixteen percent of Croatian Wikipedia articles were assessed as "insufficiently informative", as opposed to five percent of articles from the Croatian Encyclopedia.[9] The criterion of objectivity measured the neutral point of view in articles; 91% of Croatian Wikipedia articles were assessed as being neutral, as opposed to 98% in the Croatian Encyclopedia. Two percent of Croatian Wikipedia articles were assessed as non-neutral, as opposed to zero in the Croatian Encyclopedia.[9] According to their subjective preference, reviewers chose 53% of articles in the Croatian Encyclopedia as their preferred article version, while only 19.5% of Wikipedia articles were preferred, with 27% of articles being assessed as equal in quality.[10]

2013 controversy about right-wing bias

See also: Far-right politics in Croatia
Sitenotice that translates to "official and public refutation of yellow journalism by Jutarnji list"

Examples of far right biased articles

  • Ante Pavelić; once head of nazi puppet state NDH Ante Pavelić is painted as eminent croatian politician at the time but instead he war blood thursty war lord and war criminal, croatian Benito Mussolini responsible for mass murder and genocide.
  • Vjekoslav Luburić, in article questioned by numerous scholars there is no any mention he is responsible for mass murders and exterminations of thousands of native Jews and Serbs.
  • Mile Budak; in article about ideological father of all crimes and genocide in holocaust in Croatia there is severe tendency to dismiss the fact Budak is sentenced war criminal, in article it is written "In Tito's Yugoslavia he is sentenced as war criminal", which is used to dismiss the fact he is war criminal for Yugoslavia was totalitarian state.
  • Jure Francetić; responsible for numerous murders of civilians in article questioned by scholars is painted as national hero but not as war criminal.

Media reports about bias

In September 2013, complaints about right-wing bias of administrators and editors on the Croatian Wikipedia began to receive attention by the media, following the launch of a Facebook page titled Razotkrivanje sramotne hr.wikipedije (Exposing the Disgraceful hr.Wikipedia) which was created with the intent of bringing attention to the issues.[11] Reported examples of bias include historical revisionism such as watering-down and denial of the crimes committed by the Ustashe regime, and equating anti-fascism with forms of totalitarianism.[12] Other issues included the bias against Serbs of Croatia and the LGBT population.[13][14] Editors who tried to remove the biased sections were reportedly being harassed by administrators and quickly received permanent blocks under various pretexts.[15] The issue was reported by Croatia's daily Jutarnji list and even made its print edition's front page on 11 September 2013.[16]

Statements by Željko Jovanović

Two days later, Croatia's Minister of Science, Education and Sports, Željko Jovanović, called for pupils and students in Croatia to avoid using the Croatian Wikipedia.[17] In an interview given to Novi list, Jovanović said that "the idea of openness and relevance as a knowledge source that Wikipedia could and should represent has been completely discredited – which, for certain, has never been the goal of Wikipedia's creators nor the huge number of people around the world who share their knowledge and time using that medium. Croatian pupils and students have been wronged by this, so we have to warn them, unfortunately, that a large part of the content of the Croatian version of Wikipedia is not only dubious but also [contains] obvious forgeries, and therefore we invite them to use more reliable sources of information, which include Wikipedia in English and in other major languages of the world."[17] Jovanović has also commented on the Croatian Wikipedia editors – calling them a "minority group that has usurped the right to edit the Croatian-language Wikipedia".[17]

Interviews with historians

In an interview given to Index.hr, Robert Kurelić, a professor of history at the Juraj Dobrila University of Pula, has commented that "the Croatian Wikipedia is only a tool used by its administrators to promote their own political agendas, giving false and distorted facts".[18] As two particularly prominent examples he listed the Croatian Wikipedia's coverage of the term Istrijanstvo (Istrian regionalism), defined as a "movement fabricated to reduce the number of Croats", and antifašizam (anti-fascism), which according to him is defined as the opposite of what it really means.[18] Kurelić further advised "that it would be good if a larger number of people got engaged and started writing on Wikipedia", because "administrators want to exploit high-school and university students, the most common users of Wikipedia, to change their opinions and attitudes, which presents a serious issue".[18]

Snježana Koren, a historian at the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Zagreb, has judged the disputed articles as "biased and malicious, partly even illiterate", in an interview with Croatian news agency HINA.[19] She further added that "These are the types of articles you can find on the pages of fringe organizations and movements, but there should be no place for that on Wikipedia", expressing doubts on the ability of its authors to distinguish good from evil.[19] Koren concludes that the ulterior motive of such writings is to rehabilitate the Independent State of Croatia, a Nazi Germany puppet state, and that "there is no other way to characterize such efforts than as Ustashi movement".[19]

Possible sanctions for croatian wikipedia editors

It remains unclear whether central Wikipedia organization will ever question charges against Croatian Wikipedia editors for very same people which neutrality is once questioned are still as of september of 2018.g. editors of Croatian wikipedia without facing any inquiry over severe charges.

Milestones

Jimmy Wales and Croatian Wikipedians at a conference in Zagreb, October 1, 2008
  • April 25, 2003 — The first article is created
  • February 8, 2004 — 1,000 articles
  • October 8, 2005 — 10,000 articles
  • December 3, 2008 — 50,000 articles
  • July 7, 2011 — 100,000 articles
  • December 2, 2014 — 150,000 articles[20]

References

  1. ^ "Glavna stranica". Wikipedia (in Croatian). Wikimedia Foundation. Retrieved 2011-10-31.
  2. ^ "Wikipedia Statistics Croatian". stats.wikimedia.org. Wikimedia Foundation. Retrieved 2014-12-10.
  3. ^ "Izabrani članci". Croatian Wikipedia (in Croatian). Wikimedia Foundation. February 18, 2013. Retrieved 2013-02-28.
  4. ^ Kubelka & Šoštarić 2013.
  5. ^ Kubelka & Šoštarić 2013, p. 124-125.
  6. ^ Kubelka & Šoštarić 2013, p. 127.
  7. ^ Kubelka & Šoštarić 2013, p. 128.
  8. ^ Kubelka & Šoštarić 2013, p. 129.
  9. ^ a b Kubelka & Šoštarić 2013, p. 130.
  10. ^ Kubelka & Šoštarić 2013, p. 131.
  11. ^ Sampson, Tim (October 1, 2013). "How pro-fascist ideologues are rewriting Croatia's history". dailydot.com. Retrieved July 1, 2015.
  12. ^ "Fascist movement takes over Croatian Wikipedia?". InSerbia News. Retrieved 13 September 2013.
  13. ^ Trolls hijack Wikipedia to turn articles against gays, Gay Star News
  14. ^ Tko prepravlja LGBT Hrvatsku na Wikipediji?
  15. ^ "Kako je hrvatsku Wikipediju uzurpirala ustašoidna desnica" [How did pro-Ustasha right-wing editors take Croatian Wikipedia] (in Croatian). Tportal. 11 September 2013. Retrieved 11 September 2013.
  16. ^ "Desničari preuzeli uređivanje hrvatske Wikipedije" [Right-wing editors took over the Croatian Wikipedia] (in Croatian). Jutarnji list. 10 September 2013. Retrieved 11 September 2013.
  17. ^ a b c "Jovanović: Djeco, ne baratajte hrvatskom Wikipedijom jer su sadržaji falsificirani" [Jovanović: "Children, do not use the Croatian Wikipedia because its contents are forgeries"] (in Croatian). Novi list. Retrieved 13 September 2013.
  18. ^ a b c "Jovanovićeva poruka učenicima i studentima: Ne koristite hrvatsku Wikipediju!" [Jovanović's message to the pupils and students: Don't use Croatian Wikipedia!] (in Croatian). Index.hr. Retrieved 13 September 2013.
  19. ^ a b c "Hr.wikipedija pod povećalom zbog falsificiranja hrvatske povijesti" [Croatian Wikipedia under a scrutiny for fabricating Croatian history!] (in Croatian). Novi list. Retrieved 15 September 2013.
  20. ^ "Aktualno". Croatian Wikipedia (in Croatian). Wikimedia Foundation. December 7, 2014. Retrieved 2014-12-21.
Croatian edition of Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Croatian Wikipedia.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Croatian_Wikipedia&oldid=857974834"