Pyjs

Pyjs

Original author(s)	James Tauber, Google
Developer(s)	Luke Leighton, Anthony C Risinger, Kees Bos
Initial release	March 2007 (2007-03)
Stable release	0.8.1a / May 6, 2012 (2012-05-06)
Repository	github.com/pyjs/pyjs
Written in	Python, JavaScript
Operating system	Windows, OS X, Linux
Available in	Python
Type	Ajax framework, Desktop and Web Widget toolkit, Compiler, Widget set
License	Apache License 2.0
Website	pyjs.org

Pyjs (formerly Pyjamas before May 2012), is a rich Internet application framework for developing client-side web and desktop applications in Python. The resulting applications can be run in a web browser or as standalone desktop applications.

It contains a stand-alone Python-to-JavaScript compiler, an Ajax framework and widget toolkit, and through use of these components, developers can write comprehensive applications, to run in all major web browsers, without writing any JavaScript. Pyjs is a port of Google Web Toolkit (GWT) from Java to Python.

Development

Using pyjs, developers can write web applications in Python instead of JavaScript. The application is compiled to JavaScript. Also included is an Ajax library and widget set that provides access to the Document Object Model (DOM) of modern JavaScript-capable web browsers. The Ajax library and the widget set library are a hybrid mix of Python and JavaScript. Just as with Google Web Toolkit, pyjs is not its libraries, and neither is it just another Ajax framework. Ajax frameworks are strictly limited to providing pre-prepared specific functionality, written almost exclusively in tailor-made JavaScript. Both GWT and pyjs, being JavaScript compilers, allow the developer to work in the language with which they are familiar (Java or Python, respectively), to write their own custom widgets, either entirely from scratch or based on the existing available widgets, yet still target the full range of modern browsers. So, far from presenting web developers with a fait-accompli Ajax framework, pyjs gives you the freedom to develop your own.

Design

The pyjs compiler is written in the programming language Python, and uses it to compile its input into JavaScript, walking the abstract syntax tree of the program being compiled. Although the compiler is stand-alone, the primary use of pyjs is for web development, so there is additional infrastructure for building web applications.

The DOM.py model library is an abstraction layer - a thin layer of Python on top of JavaScript code snippets - use of which provides access to the full Document Object Model of the target browser platform. As with any compiler, the JavaScript snippets are treated as inline assembler.

Furthermore, on top of the DOM.py model library is an additional abstraction layer, ui.py, which provides the most useful layer to web developers: a full suite of widgets with which desktop application developers will be familiar. At present, the list of available widgets is a mixture of the complete set of widgets that were available in Google Web Toolkit 1.2, along with a few more that have been forward-ported from GWT 1.5.

Components

The major Pyjs components include:

pyjs Python-to-JavaScript Compiler

Translates the programming language Python into JavaScript.

Python builtin and standard emulation library

JavaScript implementations of the commonly used modules, builtins and classes in the Python standard runtime library (such as strings, lists, dictionaries, tuples, sets, getattr, map, filter, range, etc.; basic exception handling, a basic datetime and a basic math module).

pyjs DOM library

Modules for manipulating the browser DOM.

pyjs Web UI module

A module for creating widgets as if the web browser was a desktop widget engine.

pyjs Desktop ports

Support for running pyjs apps as pure Python, under Trident (MSHTML), Gecko (XULRunner) or WebKit. Pyjs Desktop is conceptually close to GWT "Hosted" mode, except that the applications can be deployed live, under pyjs Desktop, rather than be used exclusively as a debugging tool.

pyjs Desktop

The widget set library that comes with pyjs is so similar to PyQt and PyGTK that a port of pyjs was made to run pyjs applications on the desktop, called pyjs Desktop (formerly PyjamasDesktop before May 2012 and originally hosted separately prior to version 0.6). The project uses Webkit, XULRunner or MSHTML as the underlying technology, and it is through these browser engines that pyjs manipulates the DOM model of the application. Together pyjs and pyjs Desktop allow writing cross-platform, cross-desktop, cross-browser and cross-widget applications that run on the web and on the desktop.

History

Pyjamas was started by James Tauber as a port of the UI Widget Set and the DOM support libraries from Google Web Toolkit to the Python language. Tauber then wrote the original pyjs compiler.

In 2008, Luke Leighton took over the project, updated the UI Widget Set, improved the compiler and created the three pyjs Desktop runtimes.

Bernd Dorn and his colleagues from Lovely Systems did some dramatic compiler improvements released in version 0.5. Kees Bos is responsible for the majority of improvements and the enhanced Python interoperability in the compiler, such as the yield keyword support and long data types. C Anthony Risinger also joined as lead and administrator of the project.

In 2012, the project was driven by an extensive community, but on May 2, due to disagreements between project leaders, some members created a pyjamas fork. This new team created pyjs.org, led by Anthony Risinger and including the person who owned the domain. Meanwhile, Luke Leighton continued his work on his own fork through a new domain pyj.be and continues to develop and maintain pyjamas on this branch.

There was controversy over the copying of the mailing list data from the old server to create the new mailing list of Google Groups. This was raised as a violation of the UK Data Protection Act by Luke Leighton. Whether this was actually a legal violation is not really clear and is open to interpretation. This was a community driven open source project. According to many in the community, both Luke and Anthony were co-administrators of the project and co-leads to it. It was being forked by a team including Anthony, one of the administrators who had privileges for the server, which Luke Leighton owned. The mailing list was part of the domain. So the ownership of the mailing list data itself isn't very clear. Though Luke claims he personally owned the mailing list and that using it to create a new mailing list for the new pyjs.org fork of the project constituted stealing, many in the community feel differently. Many feel that this was an open source community project and Luke Leighton was a co-lead and co-administrator. Hence the mailing list was actually a community property of the pyjs.org community and not the personal property of Luke.

Even though the ownership of the mailing list data is not entirely clear, when some members complained about being subscribed to the new google groups mailing list, immediate action was taken by the maintainers of the new pyjs.org fork to remove everyone from the new google groups and invited all the members to voluntarily join the new google groups. This being exactly the same approach that Leighton took when he decided to move the pyjamas mailing list from google groups where it was originally created before Leighton took over leadership of the project.

The current membership of the Google Groups owned and maintained by both forks of the original pyjs.org is now voluntary, created through invitation, and does not violate any privacy and data protection laws. There are no unresolved legal issues at this time nor any pending lawsuits with either forks of the pyjamas project.

Both forks were actively developed and had formed their own community following.

Forks

There were two forks of the Pyjamas/Pyjs project: one maintained by the new Pyjs team and another maintained by Luke Leighton.

Pyjs.org

The Pyjs.org fork, has gone through active development.

• New GitHub based infrastructure
• Travis CI based continuous integration for both build, install and automated testing
• pip install and VirtualEnv based development environment
• Separation of pyjs tools from pyjs GWT widgets to allow other widgets sets to be developed
• Built-in Closure compiler integration
• GI Introspection/WebKit-GTK based pyjs-desktop runner

Pyj.be

Pyj.be, continued to be maintained by Luke Leighton and was still active with bug fixes and new development. As of early 2015, however, the website is not available anymore.

Critics

Pyjamas has been criticized by heavy users for several aspects:

• Browser detection instead of feature detection
• Bloat and boilerplate hell (Python feature coverage is favored over speed and size)
• Debugging (perfect with Pyjs Desktop, but that is broken for more than 3 years)
• Python is not Java, DOM is not a Desktop (the underlying GWT unnecessarily fakes a desktop GUI)

On the other hand, as a dynamically typed language Python is a specifically good fit for compiling code to JavaScript, actually a more natural fit than GWT's original Java-to-JavaScript approach.

Alternatives

Most alternatives to Pyjamas are translators rather than frameworks.

• Brython
• GlowScript
• py2js
• PyCow
• Pyjaco
• PyvaScript
• RapydScript
• Transcrypt

External links

• Pyjs Home