Havana syndrome

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Havana syndrome
Hotelnacionale.jpg
The Hotel Nacional in Havana is one of the locations the alleged attacks occurred.[1]
SymptomsHearing strange grating noises, headache, hearing loss, memory loss, and nausea
CausesUndetermined

Havana syndrome is a set of medical signs and symptoms experienced by United States and Canadian embassy staff in Cuba. Beginning in August 2017, reports surfaced that American and Canadian diplomatic personnel in Cuba had suffered a variety of health problems, dating back to late 2016.[2][3]

The US government accused Cuba of perpetrating unspecified attacks causing these symptoms. The US reduced staff at their embassy to a minimum, and US President Trump declared in October 2017 that he believed Cuba was responsible for the attacks.[4]

Subsequent studies of the affected diplomats in Cuba, published in the journal JAMA in 2018, found evidence that the diplomats experienced some form of brain injury, but did not determine the cause of the injuries.[5][6] A co-author of the JAMA study considered microwave weapons to be "a main suspect" for the phenomenon.[7] A 2018 study published in the journal Neural Computation identified pulsed radiofrequency/microwave radiation (RF/MW) exposure via the Frey effect as source of injury, and noted that a microwave attack against the US embassy in Moscow has been historically documented.[8] Other researchers have posited other possible causes for the injuries, including ultrasound via intermodulation distortion caused by malfunctioning or improperly placed Cuban surveillance equipment;[9][10] cricket noises,[11][12] and exposure to neurotoxic pesticides.[13][14] Early speculation of an acoustic or sonic cause was later determined to be unfounded.[8] Some had suggested that the symptoms represented episodes of mass hysteria,[15] but the 2018 JAMA researchers considered a "wholly psychogenic or psychosomatic cause" to be very unlikely, given the physical evidence of brain trauma.[6]

In 2018, US diplomats in China reported problems similar to those reported in Cuba, as well as undercover C.I.A. agents operating in other countries who were negotiating with those countries on ways to counter Russian covert operations around the world.[16][17]

Cuba[edit]

Cuba

In August 2017, reports began surfacing that American and Canadian[18] diplomatic personnel in Cuba had experienced unusual, unexplained health problems dating back to late 2016.[19][20] The number of American citizens experiencing symptoms was 26 as of June 2018.[21]

Events[edit]

The health problems typically had a sudden onset: the victim would suddenly begin hearing strange grating noises that they perceived as coming from a specific direction. Some of them experienced it as a pressure or a vibration; or as a sensation comparable to driving a car with the window partly rolled down. The duration of these noises ranged from 20 seconds to 30 minutes, and always happened while the diplomats were either at home or in hotel rooms. Other people nearby, family members and guests in neighboring rooms, did not report hearing anything.[22] The Associated Press has released what it said was a recording of the sound some embassy workers heard while in Cuba.[23]

Impact on American diplomats[edit]

Some US embassy individuals have experienced lasting health effects, including one unidentified US diplomat who is said to now need a hearing aid.[24] The State Department declared that the health problems were either the result of an attack, or due to exposure to an as-yet-unknown device,[25] and declared that they were not blaming the Cuban government, but would not say who was to blame.[26] Affected individuals described symptoms such as hearing loss, memory loss, and nausea.[25] Speculation centered around a sonic weapon,[27] with some researchers pointing to infrasound as a possible cause.[28]

In August 2017, the United States expelled two Cuban diplomats in response to the illnesses.[19] In September, the US State Department stated that it was removing non-essential staff from the US embassy, and warned US citizens not to travel to Cuba.[29] In October 2017, US President Trump said that "I do believe Cuba's responsible. I do believe that",[30] going on to say "And it's a very unusual attack, as you know. But I do believe Cuba is responsible."[4]

On March 2, 2018, the US State Department announced it would continue to staff its embassy in Havana at the minimum level required to perform "core diplomatic and consular functions" due to concerns about health attacks on staff. The embassy had been operating under "ordered departure status" since September, but the status was set to expire. This announcement served to extend the staff reductions indefinitely.[31]

Investigations by the US government[edit]

In January 2018, the Associated Press reported that a non-public FBI report found no evidence of an intentional sonic attack.[32] A November 2018 report in the New Yorker found that the FBI's investigation into the incidents was stymied by conflict with the CIA and the State Department; the CIA was reluctant to reveal, even to other US government agencies, the identities of affected officers, because of the CIA's concern about possible leaks. Federal rules on the privacy of employee medical records also hindered the investigation.[33]

In January 2018, at the direction of Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, the Department of State conveyed an Accountability Review Board,[34] which is "an internal State Department mechanism to review security incidents involving diplomatic personnel."[35] Retired United States Ambassador to Libya Peter Bodde was chosen to lead the board.[35]

Impact on Canadian diplomats[edit]

In March 2018, MRI scans and other tests taken by a chief neurologist in Pittsburgh, on an unspecified number of Canadian diplomats showed evidence of brain damage that mirrored the injuries some of their American counterparts had faced. In spring of 2018, Global Affairs Canada ended family postings to Cuba and withdrew all staff with families. Several of the Canadians who were impacted in 2017 were reported to still be unable to resume their work due to the severity of their ailments. The fact that there is presently no knowledge of the cause of “Havana syndrome” has made it challenging for the RCMP to investigate.[36]

In 2019, the government of Canada announced that it was reducing its embassy staff in Havana after a 14th Canadian diplomat reported symptoms of Havana syndrome in late December 2018.[37] In February 2019, several Canadian diplomats sued the Canadian government, arguing that it failed to protect them or promptly address serious health concerns.[38][39] The government has sought to dismiss the suit, arguing in a November 2019 that it was not negligent and did not breach its duties to its employees. In court filings, the government acknowledged that several of the 14 plaintiffs in the suit suffered from concussion-like symptoms, but said that no definitive cause or medical diagnosis had been ascertained.[40] In a November 2019 statement, Global Affairs Canada said, "We continue to investigate the potential causes of the unusual health symptoms."[40]

Cuban government reactions[edit]

After the incident was made public, the Cuban Foreign Minister subsequently accused the US of lying about the incident,[41] saying "There is no evidence, there is no evidence whatsoever, of the occurrence of the alleged incidents or the cause or origin of these ailments reported by US diplomats," adding, "Neither is there any evidence suggesting that these health problems have been caused by an attack of any sort during their stay in Cuba."[42]

The Cuban government offered to cooperate with the US in an investigation of the incidents.[43] It employed about 2000 scientists and law enforcement officers who interviewed 300 neighbors of diplomats, examined two hotels, and also medically examined non-diplomats who could have been exposed. NBC reported that Cuban officials stated that they analyzed air and soil samples, and considered a range of toxic chemicals. They also examined the possibility that electromagnetic waves were to blame, and even looked into whether insects could be the culprit, but found nothing they could link to the claimed medical symptoms. The FBI and Cuban authorities met to discuss the situation; the Cubans stated that the US neither agreed to share the diplomats' medical records with Cuban authorities nor allowed Cuban investigators access to US diplomats' homes to conduct tests.[44]

Studies regarding injury[edit]

At the request of the US government, University of Pennsylvania researchers examined 21 affected diplomats, and the preliminary results were published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) in March 2018. The report "found no evidence of white matter tract abnormalities" in affected diplomats, beyond what might be seen in a control group of the same age, and described "a new syndrome in the diplomats that resembles persistent concussion."[45][46] While some of those affected recovered swiftly, others had symptoms lasting for months. The study concluded that "the diplomats appear to have sustained injury to widespread brain networks."[45][46] Some experts criticized the study, arguing that there was "no proof that any kind of energy source affected the diplomats, or even that an attack took place."[45] Subsequent study findings by the University of Pennsylvania team, published in July 2019, found that compared to a healthy control group, the diplomats who had reported injury had experienced brain trauma; advanced MRI scans (specifically res-fMRI, multimodal MRI, and diffusion MRI) revealed "differences in whole brain white matter volume, regional gray and white matter volume, cerebellar microstructural integrity, and functional connectivity in the auditory and visuospatial subnetworks" but found no differences in executive functions.[5][6] The study concluded that the US government personnel had been physically injured in a way consistent with the symptoms that they described, but expressed no conclusion on the cause or source of the injury.[5][6] The New York Times reported: "Outside experts were divided on the study's conclusions. Some saw important new evidence; others say it is merely a first step toward an explanation, and difficult to interpret given the small number of patients."[6]

Theories regarding cause[edit]

A cause or source of the phenomenon has never been definitively determined.[6][7] In 2018, US State Department medical director Dr. Charles Rosenfarb testified to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that the "unique constellation of symptoms and findings" had "no obvious cause."[47]

Microwaves[edit]

In a 2018 interview, Douglas H. Smith, a co-author of the JAMA study, said that microwaves were "considered a main suspect" underlying the phenomenon.[7] A 2018 study published in the journal Neural Computation by Beatrice Alexandra Golomb rejected the idea that a sonic attack was the source of the symptoms, and concluded that the facts were consistent with pulsed radiofrequency/microwave radiation (RF/MW) exposure as the source of injury. Golomb wrote that (1) the nature of the noises reported by the diplomats was consistent with sounds caused by pulsed RF/MW via the Frey effect; (2) the signs and symptoms reported by the diplomats matched symptoms from RF/MW exposure (problems with sleep, cognition, vision, balance, speech; headaches; sensations of pressure or vibration; nosebleeds; brain injury and brain swelling); (3) "oxidative stress provides a documented mechanism of RF/MW injury compatible with reported signs and symptoms"; and (4) in the past, the US embassy in Moscow was subject to a microwave attack.[8] Neuroscientist Allan H. Frey, for whom the Frey effect is named, considered the microwave theory to be viable.[7] Some other scientists, including physicist Peter Zimmerman and bioengineer Kenneth R. Foster, disagreed, considering the microwave hypothesis to be implausible.[47]

Ultrasounds[edit]

In March 2018, Kevin Fu and a team of computer scientists at the University of Michigan reported in a study that ultrasound—specifically, intermodulation distortion from multiple inaudible ultrasonic signals—from malfunctioning or improperly placed Cuban surveillance equipment could have been the origin of the reported sounds.[9][10][48]

In January 2019, biologists Alexander L. Stubbs of the University of California, Berkeley and Fernando Montealegre-Z of the University of Lincoln analyzed a recording of a sound made by US personnel in Cuba and release to the Associated Press. Stubbs and Montealegre-Z concluded that the sound was caused by the calling song of the Indies short-tailed cricket (Anurogryllus celerinictus) rather than a technological device. Stubbs and Montealegre-Z matched the song's "pulse repetition rate, power spectrum, pulse rate stability, and oscillations per pulse" to the recording.[49][11] Stubbs and Montealegre wrote that "Although the causes of the health problems reported by embassy personnel are beyond the scope of this paper and called for "more rigorous research into the source of these ailments, including the potential psychogenic effects, as well as possible physiological explanations unrelated to sonic attacks."[11] This conclusion was comparable to a 2017 hypothesis from Cuban scientists that the sound on the same recording is from Jamaican field crickets.[49][50][12][51] Reuters reported that JASON, a group of physicists and scientists who advise the US government, determined that "a rare jungle cricket" was the cause of the sounds in Havana.[52]

Psychogenic origin[edit]

In 2017, 2018, and 2019 sociologist Robert Bartholomew[53][54][55] and some neurologists wrote that the attacks represent episodes of mass psychogenic illness.[15][56][57][58][50] However, the co-lead author of the 2019 study published in JAMA, Ragini Verma of the University of Pennsylvania Perlman School of Medicine, considered a "wholly psychogenic or psychosomatic cause" to be very unlikely, given the researchers' findings,[6] and State Department medical director Dr. Charles Rosenfarb testified that the department had "all but ruled out 'mass hysteria" as a cause.[54][59][60]

Pesticides[edit]

A study commissioned by Global Affairs Canada of 23 exposed Canadian diplomats, completed in May 2019, found "clinical, imaging, and biochemical evidence consistent with the hypothesis" that over-exposure to cholinesterase inhibitors (a class of neurotoxic pesticide) such as pyrethroid and organophosphate as a cause of brain injury; the embassies and other places in Cuba had been sprayed frequently as an anti-Zika virus mosquito control measure.[13][14][61] The study concluded that other possible causes could not be ruled out.[13]

Guangzhou, China[edit]

In early 2018, accusations similar to those reported by diplomats in Cuba began to be made by US diplomats in China. The first incident reported by an American diplomat in China was in April 2018 at the Consulate General of the United States, Guangzhou, the largest US consulate in China. The employee reported that he had been experiencing symptoms since late 2017. Several individuals were taken to the United States for medical examination.[16][62][63] Another incident had previously been reported by a USAID employee at the US Embassy in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, in September 2017; the employee's report was discounted by the US State Department.[64]

Answering questions from the House Foreign Affairs Committee on May 23, 2018, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo confirmed that there had been reports from US diplomatic staff in Guangzhou of symptoms "very similar" to, and "entirely consistent" with, those reported from Cuba.[65][66] On June 6, 2018, The New York Times reported that at least two additional US diplomats stationed at the Guangzhou consulate had been evacuated from China, and reported that "it remains unclear whether the illnesses are the result of attacks at all. Other theories have included toxins, listening devices that accidentally emitted harmful sounds, or even mass hysteria."[62] In June 2018, the State Department announced that a task force had been assembled to investigate the reports[67] and expanded their health warning to all of mainland China amid reports some US diplomats outside of Guangzhou had experienced the same symptoms resembling a brain injury.[68] The warning told anyone who experienced "unusual acute auditory or sensory phenomena accompanied by unusual sounds or piercing noises" to "not attempt to locate their source."[69]

Theories regarding culprit[edit]

Several US State Department employees who consider themselves victims, and some senior CIA Russian analysts, as well as some outside scientists believe Russia is the most likely culprit. Russia has been accused by the US State Department of using directed microwaves in the past. During the Cold War, the US accused Russia of directing a microwave signal at the American embassy in Moscow, and a 2014 NSA report raised suspicions that Russia used an energy weapon to "bathe a target’s living quarters in microwaves", which caused nervous system damage. The purported targets in the 2016-2018 events include undercover CIA agents who were working on ways to counter Russian covert operations. Also, US diplomats claiming to be targeted in China and Cuba were working to increase cooperation with those countries. Some CIA analysts suspect Russia was trying to disrupt all those activities.[17]

According to New York Times sources in the US government, CIA director, Gina Haspel and other leaders in the State Department are unconvinced that Russia is responsible or even whether an attack occurred. However, some believe there is a high-level and deliberate cover-up by the Trump-led State Department after an investigation "found a substantial likelihood of wrongdoing" by State.[17]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Cuba Travel Advisory". Travel.state.gov. Department of State. January 10, 2018. Archived from the original on January 30, 2018. Retrieved June 22, 2018.
  2. ^ Entous, Adam; Anderson, Jon Lee (November 19, 2018). "The Mystery of the Havana Syndrome: Unexplained brain injuries afflicted dozens of American diplomats and spies. What happened?". The New Yorker.
  3. ^ Payne, Elizabeth (November 30, 2018). "Ottawa doctor treating Canadian diplomats with mysterious 'Havana syndrome'". Ottawa Citizen. It is being called Havana syndrome and officials in Canada and the United States, where more than 20 diplomats have been affected, are trying to identify the cause of the injuries.
  4. ^ a b "Trump says Cuba 'responsible' for alleged sonic attacks, but offers no evidence". The Guardian. October 16, 2017. Retrieved December 7, 2017.
  5. ^ a b c Ragini Verma; Randel L. Swanson; Drew Parker; et al. (2019). "Neuroimaging Findings in US Government Personnel With Possible Exposure to Directional Phenomena in Havana, Cuba". JAMA. 322 (4): 336–347. doi:10.1001/jama.2019.9269. PMC 6652163. PMID 31334794.
  6. ^ a b c d e f g Benedict Carey (July 23, 2019). "Were U.S. Diplomats Attacked in Cuba? Brain Study Deepens Mystery". New York Times.
  7. ^ a b c d Broad, William J. (September 1, 2018). "Microwave Weapons Are Prime Suspect in Ills of U.S. Embassy Workers". New York Times. Retrieved September 2, 2018.
  8. ^ a b c Golomb, Beatrice Alexandra (November 2018). "Diplomats' Mystery Illness and Pulsed Radiofrequency/Microwave Radiation". Neural Computation. 30 (11): 2882–2985. doi:10.1162/neco_a_01133. ISSN 0899-7667. PMID 30183509. S2CID 52162053.
  9. ^ a b "On Cuba, Diplomats, Ultrasound, and Intermodulation Distortion" (PDF). University of Michigan Tech Report CSE-TR-001-18. March 1, 2018.
  10. ^ a b Torres, Nora Gámez (March 2, 2018). "Computer scientists may have solved the mystery behind the 'sonic attacks' in Cuba". Miami Herald. Archived from the original on April 22, 2018. Retrieved April 22, 2018.
  11. ^ a b c Alexander L. Stubbs & Fernando Montealegre-Z (2019). "Recording of "sonic attacks" on U.S. diplomats in Cuba spectrally matches the echoing call of a Caribbean cricket". doi:10.1101/510834. S2CID 92213135 – via bioRxiv. Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  12. ^ a b Stone, Richard (December 8, 2017). "Cuban panel claims stress caused mystery illnesses". Science. AAAS. 358 (6368): 1236–1237. Bibcode:2017Sci...358.1236S. doi:10.1126/science.358.6368.1236. PMID 29217550.
  13. ^ a b c Alon Friedman; Cindy Calkin; Chris Bowen (May 24, 2019). Havana Syndrome: Neuroanatomical and Neurofunctional Assessment in Acquired Brain Injury Due to Unknown Etiology (Report). Retrieved September 20, 2019 – via Scribd.
  14. ^ a b Luc Chartrand, Martin Movilla and Lisa Ellenwood (September 19, 2019). "Havana syndrome: Exposure to neurotoxin may have been cause, study suggests". Retrieved September 20, 2019.
  15. ^ a b Julian Borger and Philip Jaekl (October 12, 2017). "Mass hysteria may explain 'sonic attacks' in Cuba, say top neurologists". The Guardian. Retrieved October 14, 2017.
  16. ^ a b "China Pledges to Investigate Fears of Sonic Attacks on U.S. Diplomats". The New York Times. June 7, 2018.
  17. ^ a b c Ana Swanson (October 19, 2020). "U.S. Diplomats and Spies Battle Trump Administration Over Suspected Attacks". The New York Times. Retrieved October 20, 2020.
  18. ^ "Mystery of sonic weapon attacks at US embassy in Cuba deepens". The Guardian. September 14, 2017.
  19. ^ a b Neuman, Scott (August 9, 2017). "Cuban Diplomats Expelled After US Embassy Staff 'Incidents' In Havana". NPR. Retrieved October 1, 2017.
  20. ^ Connor, Tracy; Murray, Mary; Williams, Abigail (September 17, 2017). "Victim of Cuba embassy 'attacks' frustrated by response". NBC News. Retrieved October 1, 2017.
  21. ^ "U.S. says another American suffers illness at its Cuba embassy". Reuters. June 28, 2018. Retrieved July 3, 2018.
  22. ^ Hurley, Dan (March 22, 2018). "The Mystery Behind Neurological Symptoms Among US Diplomats in Cuba: Lots of Questions, Few Answers". Neurology Today. 18 (6): 1, 24–26. doi:10.1097/01.NT.0000532085.86007.9b.
  23. ^ Josh Lederman & Michael Weissenstein (October 13, 2017). "Dangerous sound? What Americans heard in Cuba attacks". Associated Press. Retrieved October 27, 2020.
  24. ^ Zachary Cohen. "New audio adds to mystery of Cuba attacks". CNN. Retrieved October 14, 2017.
  25. ^ a b Doubek, James. "At Least 16 U.S. Embassy Staff In Cuba Treated After 'Health Attacks'". NPR.
  26. ^ U.S. does not believe Cuba is behind sonic attacks on American diplomats. McClatchy News Service, 26 September 2017
  27. ^ Chavez, Nicole. "Using sound to attack: The diverse world of acoustic devices". CNN.
  28. ^ Catherine McIntyre (August 24, 2017). "How Canadian diplomats in Cuba are being acoustically attacked". Maclean's.
  29. ^ Rich Edson (September 29, 2017). "US stops issuing visas in Cuba, cuts embassy staff, urges no travel to island". Fox News. Retrieved October 1, 2017.
  30. ^ Zachary Cohen. "Trump blames Cuba for mysterious attacks on US diplomats". CNN. Retrieved December 7, 2017.
  31. ^ Koran, Laura; Oppmann, Patrick (March 2, 2018). "US Embassy in Cuba to reduce staff indefinitely after 'health attacks'". CNN. Retrieved April 22, 2018.
  32. ^ Josh Lederman & Matthew Lee, Tillerson tells AP Cuba still risky; FBI doubts sonic attack, Associated Press (January 8, 2018).
  33. ^ Adam Entous & Jon Lee Anderson, The Mystery of the Havana Syndrome, New Yorker (November 9, 2018).
  34. ^ "Tillerson to order new probe of Havana embassy health "attacks"". Reuters. January 9, 2018. Archived from the original on April 7, 2018. Retrieved April 7, 2018.
  35. ^ a b "Retired ambassador to Libya to lead Cuba attacks review". CNN. Retrieved January 10, 2018.
  36. ^ "Blood and bureaucracy: Inside Canada's panicked response to 'Havana syndrome'". Retrieved February 7, 2019.
  37. ^ "‘Havana Syndrome’ forces Canada to halve its diplomatic presence in Cuba". Radio Canada International, January 30, 2019.
  38. ^ "Ailing Canadian diplomats who served in Cuba have 'visible and real' health impacts, Trudeau". The Star. Retrieved February 7, 2019.
  39. ^ Dan Bilefsky, Canadian Diplomats Sue Their Government Over Mysterious Cuban Disease, New York Times (February 7, 2019).
  40. ^ a b Brian Platt, In court filing, Canadian government argues diplomats exaggerated 'Havana Syndrome' claims behind $28M lawsuit, National Post (November 26, 2019).
  41. ^ "Cuba official accuses US of lying about sonic attacks". Associated Press. November 3, 2017. Retrieved December 7, 2017.
  42. ^ Gaouette, Nicole (November 2, 2017). "Cuban Minister rejects US sonic attack claims". CNN. Retrieved January 7, 2018.
  43. ^ "Statement by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Cuba". Minrex.gob.cu. Minrex. August 9, 2017. Archived from the original on April 7, 2018. Retrieved April 7, 2018.
  44. ^ Mitchell, Andrea; Murray, Mary (October 24, 2017). "Cubans Forcefully Reject Blame for U.S. Diplomats' Mystery Ailments". NBC News.
  45. ^ a b c Sample, Ian (February 24, 2018). "Fresh row over mysterious sickness affecting US diplomats in Cuba". The Guardian.
  46. ^ a b Randel L. Swanson II; Stephen Hampton; Judith Green-McKenzie; et al. (2018). "Neurological Manifestations Among US Government Personnel Reporting Directional Audible and Sensory Phenomena in Havana, Cuba". JAMA. 319 (11): 1125–1133. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.1742. PMC 5885885. PMID 29450484.
  47. ^ a b Kaplan, Sarah; Achenbach, Joel (September 6, 2018). "Scientists and doctors zap theory that microwave weapon injured Cuba diplomats". Washington Post.
  48. ^ McKay, Tom (March 3, 2018). "Study: Malfunctioning Surveillance Gear, Not Sonic Weapons, Could Explain Cuba Embassy 'Attack'". Gizmodo.com. Gizmodo. Archived from the original on April 22, 2018. Retrieved April 22, 2018.
  49. ^ a b Zimmer, Carl (January 4, 2019). "The Sounds That Haunted U.S. Diplomats in Cuba? Lovelorn Crickets, Scientists Say". New York Times.
  50. ^ a b Stone, Richard (February 15, 2018). "U.S. diplomats in Cuba have unusual brain syndrome, but there's no proof they were attacked, study says". Science. AAAS. doi:10.1126/science.aat3410.
  51. ^ Stone, Richard (June 20, 2018). "Sonic attack or mass paranoia? New evidence stokes debate over diplomats' mysterious illness". Science. AAAS. doi:10.1126/science.aau5386 (inactive October 22, 2020). Retrieved July 24, 2019.CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of October 2020 (link)
  52. ^ Levinson, Charles (July 30, 2019). "Special Report: Inside a Trump-era purge of military scientists at a legendary think tank". Reuters.
  53. ^ Bures, Frank (February 1, 2018). "Cuba's Sonic Attacks Show Us Just How Susceptible Our Brains Are to Mass Hysteria". Slate. Retrieved April 1, 2018.
  54. ^ a b Bartholomew, Robert E. (January 10, 2018). "'Sonic Attack' Not Mass Hysteria, Says Top Doc – He's Wrong!". Psychology Today. Archived from the original on April 7, 2018. Retrieved April 7, 2018.
  55. ^ Palmer, Robert (February 5, 2019). "Were The 'Sonic Attacks' On American Diplomats Just Sci-Fi?". Skepticalinquirer.org. CFI. Archived from the original on December 8, 2019. Retrieved December 8, 2019. Any talk of a sonic attack is science fiction … . I have no doubt that the Trump Administration, which has consistently claimed that an attack took place (including Trump himself), now realize that they have made a mistake, but they do not want to admit it … . As for the Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearings chaired by Senator Marco Rubio, it was a sham.
  56. ^ Borger, Julian; Jaekl, Philip. "Mass hysteria may explain 'sonic attacks' in Cuba, say top neurologists". The Guardian. Retrieved February 27, 2018.
  57. ^ Hignett, Katherine. "Mass Hysteria or Microwave Weapon – What's Behind the 'Sonic Attacks' on U.S. Diplomats in Cuba?". Newsweek. Retrieved February 27, 2018.
  58. ^ Da Silva, Chantal. "As U.S. Accuses Cuba of Sonic Attacks, Canada Keeps Diplomats in Country Despite Mystery Illnesses". Newsweek. Retrieved February 26, 2018.
  59. ^ Bartholomew, Robert E. (January 16, 2018). "Sonic Attack Claims Are Unjustified: Just Follow the Facts". CSI. Archived from the original on April 7, 2018. Retrieved April 7, 2018.
  60. ^ Bartholomew, Robert E. "The "Sonic Attack" On U.S. Diplomats in Cuba: Why the State Department's Claims Don't Add Up". Skeptic Magazine. Archived from the original on October 25, 2017. Retrieved April 7, 2018.
  61. ^ Frank, Marc (September 19, 2019). "Neurotoxin may have caused diplomats' illness in Cuba: study". Reuters. Retrieved September 19, 2019.
  62. ^ a b Steven Lee Myers & Jane Perlez (June 6, 2018). "U.S. Diplomats Evacuated in China as Medical Mystery Grows". The New York Times.
  63. ^ "US diplomats evacuated from China amid 'sonic attack' concerns". CNET. June 6, 2018.
  64. ^ Dorsey, Steve (November 28, 2017). "Uzbekistan incident raises suspicions of Russian involvement in Cuba attacks". CBS News. Retrieved June 8, 2018.
  65. ^ Gardiner Harris, Pompeo Says Mysterious Sickness Among Diplomats in Cuba Has Spread to China, New York Times (May 23, 2018).
  66. ^ Steven Jiang, Ben Westcott and Maegan Vazquez (March 23, 2018). "Pompeo says China incident 'entirely consistent' with Cuba 'sonic attacks'". CNN.
  67. ^ Kuo, Lily (June 7, 2018). "'Sonic attack' fears as more US diplomats fall ill in China". the Guardian.
  68. ^ "U.S. expands China health alert amid illness reports". Reuters. June 7, 2018.
  69. ^ Achenbach, Joel (June 8, 2018). "Controversy surrounds research on State Department employees sickened in 'attacks'". The Washington Post. Retrieved June 10, 2018.

External links[edit]