Islam and Jainism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Islam and Jainism interacted with each other in the Indian subcontinent following the Islamic conquest of the subcontinent from Central Asia and Persia in the seventh to the twelfth centuries, and thereafter when much of Northwest, north and central India came under the rule of the Delhi Sultanate, and later the Mughal Empire.

Jainism and Islam have different theological premises,[1] and their interaction has been mixed ranging from religious persecution to mutual acceptance. Jains faced persecution during and after the Muslim conquests on the Indian subcontinent.[2][3] There were significant exceptions, such as Emperor Akbar (1542–1605) whose legendary religious tolerance, out of respect for Jains, ordered release of caged birds and banned killing of animals on the Jain festival of Paryusan.[4]

Muslim conquerors and Jain institutions[edit]

The first mosque built in Delhi, the "Quwwat al-Islam" (near Qutb Minar) was built after the Jain temples built previously under the Tomara dynasty were forcefully converted into Mosques by the Muslim Sultanate.[5] 27 Jain temples were demolished to build this mosque whose name translates to "might of Islam". The remains of the temple were used for to provide the building material for the mosque.[6] Similarly the Jami Masjid at Khambhat was built on ruins of Jain temples.[7]

In the year 782, the city of Vallabhi, which was an important Jain center, was destroyed by Arab rulers of Sindh.[8] Mahmud Ghazni (1001), Mohammad Ghori (1175) and Ala-ud-din Muhammed Shah Khilji (1298) further oppressed the Jain community.[9] They vandalized idols and destroyed temples or converted them into mosques. They also burned Jain books and killed many people.[9]

Muslims also destroyed many Jain holy sites during their rule in western India. They exerted serious pressure on the Jain community during 13th and 14th century.[10] Jains were powerless against the dominance of Islam at that time.[11]

A mosque in Khambhat

The Shrine of Ibrahim at Bhadreshwar in Gujarat, built in 1160 AD was built before Islamic conquest. Mehrdad Shokoohy regards the Muslim monuments at Bhadreshwar to be the earliest Muslim monument in India based on archaeological evidence[12] with architecture similar to the Jain temples of Mt Abu. According to Jain text Jagaducharitra, a grant was provided by the Jain ruler Jagdu Shah for the construction of a mosque.

Jainism in the Delhi Sultanate[edit]

Founders and rulers of Delhi Sultanate such as Mohammad Ghori (1175) and Ala-ud-din Muhammed Shah Khilji (1298) oppressed the Jain community.[3]

Jinaprabha Suri (d.1333) writes in his "Vividhatirthakalpa" ("Guide to Various Pilgrimage Places") of his relationship with Muhammad bin Tughluq (r.1325-1351), Sultan of Delhi. In two chapters that discuss his relationship with the Sultan (one of which was actually written by his disciple), Jinaprabha travels to Delhi to recover an image that had been taken from a temple. After impressing the Sultan with his poetic flair and his thorough knowledge of the various religious and philosophical schools in India. In the second chapter, Jinaprabha is called back to Delhi to settle some religious matters for the Sultan. After getting the image back from the Sultan's treasury, Jinaprabha is paraded around the town on an elephant as a display of his pre-eminence in debate. He accompanies the Sultan on his military campaigns and upon his return is awarded a quarter of town in Tughluqabad for the Jain community, including a hall for Jinaprabha to teach in. Amid great fanfare and celebration the Jain community is declared by our author as prosperous and "just as when the Hindus ruled and times were not so bad, the glorious Jinaprabhasuri taught all those who come to him, even those of other faiths, and all rush to serve him."[13] Jinaprabha also secured edicts (firmans) to allow Jains to go on pilgrimage unharmed and untaxed (ibid.). While temples were desecrated, Jinaprabha speaks of these incidents as due to the power of the Dark Age (Kali Yuga) in which such things are going to happen. He also speaks of these desecrations as opportunities to earn "endless merit" by restoring temples, which laymen did with gusto.[14]

In the Digambara tradition, the founding of the Bhattaraka tradition in its modern form (as an orange-robed monk), is often attributed to Prabhachandra of Mula Sangh, Balatkara Gana Saraswati gachchha, who travelled from Pattana (Gujarat) to Delhi, where he was anointed in a ceremony as the first Bhattaraka of Delhi. He was invited by the ruler of Delhi, who is identified as Muhammad Bin Tughlaq.[15]

Jainism in the Mughal period[edit]

As bankers and financiers, the Jains had significant impact on Muslim rulers, but they rarely were able to enter into a political discourse which was framed in Islamic categories.[16]

Some Jain customs and characters that influenced the Mughal court of Akbar have been documented. Akbar honored Hiravijaya, the leader of the Svetambara Tapa Gaccha.[17] They persuaded the emperor to forbid the slaughter of animals for six months in Gujarat and abolish the confiscation of property of deceased persons, the Sujija Tax (jizya) and a Sulka (possibly a tax on pilgrims) and free caged birds and prisoners. Akbar is said to have given up hunting and quit meat-eating forever as it had become repulsive.[17] Akbar also declared "Amari Ghosana" banning the killing of animals during Jain festival of Paryushana and Mahavir Jayanti. He rolled back the jizya from Jain pilgrimage places like Palitana. These farmans were also issued in 1592, 1594 and 1598.[17] Jain monks gained the respect of the Mughal emperors Jahangir[18] and Shah Jahan. Akbar banned animal slaughter near important Jain sites during the Paryushana.[19]

In 1645, the Mughal prince Aurangzeb, after being appointed the Governor of Gujarat, ordered the slaughter a cow inside the Chintamani Parshvanath Jain temple constructed by the Jain jeweller and banker Shantidas Jhaveri, according to the French traveller Jean de Thévenot (1666).[20] Aurangzeb then caused the desecration of the noses of all carved figures in the temple, and then converted the place into a mosque called Quvval-ul-Islam ("the Might of Islam").[20] Shantidas likely complained to Aurangzeb's father emperor Shah Jahan. Few years later, in 1648, Shah Jahan issued a firman declaring that a wall be constructed between the mihrabs to separate the Muslim area and Jain area, and Jain part be handed back to Shantidas so that Jains can worship in that part. The firman also declared that the Muslim fakirs housed in the building be removed, and the materials carried away from the temple should be restored.[20][21] However, Shantidas and the Jain community removed the principal images from the desecrated building and installed them in other Jain temples, did not attempt to restore it and the temple disappeared for all practical purposes.[20]

Conversions[edit]

Jain literature includes legends of debates between Muslim pirs with Jain scholars, with latter prevailing and causing the Muslim saints to convert to Jainism.[22]

According to Von Glasenapp, the Arab poet Al-Maʿarri was influenced by Jainism, in adopting non-violence, vegetarianism, animal rights and an ascetic lifestyle.[23] Other scholars state that Al-Maʿarri abandoned Islam, and his writings offended many Muslims of his times as well as attracted hundreds of followers.[24]

Similarities[edit]

Both Jainism and Islam place value on ritual fasting. The ascetic practices and festive occasions in Jainism involve fasting. In Islam, Sawm (Muslim Fasting for Ramadan) is a month long mandatory ritual fasting by Muslims.[25] One major difference is that during Sawm fasts in Islam, fasting is limited to daylight hours, and Muslims break their fast after sunset. In Jain fasting fasting continues during day and night, and Jains break their fast 48 minutes after the sunrise of the day when fast ends. Another difference is that Jain practice is optional and set by the preferences of the Jain any time of the year. In contrast, the month long fasting in Islam is a part of the mandatory five pillars of Islam practice that is set by the Islamic calendar.[25]

Differences[edit]

Creator god[edit]

Jains, unlike Muslims, do not believe in a creator God.[26][27][1]

Theology[edit]

There is neither eternal heaven nor eternal hell nor judgement day in Jainism, unlike Islam.[28][29][30] Jainism accepts numerous deities (gods and goddesses) that are a part of the cycles of rebirth,[27] while Islam is strictly monotheistic.[31]

Animal rights and food[edit]

The non-violence doctrine of Jainism has encouraged a strict vegetarian Jain culture.[32] Islam teaches that meat is a gift of God, such as in verses 6:141-142 of the Quran.[33][Quran 6:142] Muslims are generally non-vegetarians, and consume halal meat.[34] Beef is a sought after meat among Muslims, but they strictly avoid pork and alcohol.[35] Jains oppose any slaughter of animals. Muslims ritually celebrate large scale slaughter of animals for meat, such as on the festival of Eid al-Adha.[33]

Judgement day versus cyclic rebirth[edit]

Islamic scriptures reject any idea of reincarnation of human beings or God.[36][37][38] It teaches a linear concept of life, wherein a human being has only one life and upon death is judged by God, then rewarded in heaven or punished in hell.[36][39] Islam teaches final resurrection and Judgement Day,[37] but there is no prospect of reincarnation of a human being into a different body or being.[36] In contrast, the reincarnation (rebirth) doctrine, along with its theories of Saṃsāra and Karma, are central to Jain theological foundations, as evidenced by the extensive literature on it in the major sects of Jainism, and their ideas on these topics from the earliest times of the Jaina tradition.[40][41] Reincarnation in contemporary Jainism traditions is the belief that the worldly life is characterized by continuous rebirths and suffering in various realms of existence, and that a spiritual and ethical life is a means to end suffering and rebirths.[42][41][43]

Asceticism and monasticism[edit]

Asceticism is celebrated and a major part of Jain theology and salvation process.[44][45] Mainstream Islam has lacked asceticism, except for its minority Sufi sect.[46][47]

Monasticism is cherished in Jainism.[48] Monasticism is forbidden in Islam.[49]

Apostasy[edit]

Apostasy, that is abandonment of Islam by a Muslim and conversion to another religion or atheism, is a religious crime in Islamic jurisprudence punishable by death. The Quran promises dire consequences to those who "turn from", "renounce" or "disbelieve after having believed".[50][51] According to the Hadiths, states John Esposito, leaving Islam is punishable by "beheading, crucifixion or banishment", and Sharia (Islamic legal code) traditionally has required death by the sword for an adult sane male who voluntarily leaves Islam.[50] However, adds Esposito, modern thinkers have argued against execution as penalty for apostasy from Islam by invoking Quranic verse 2:257.[50]

Jainism allows freedom of conscience and apostasy. Conversions of Jains to other religions, and the marriage of a Hindu king and Jain queen wherein each continued to follow their religion, and build temples of both religions, has been documented in Jain history.[52][53] In some Digambara Jain writings, the Buddha is presented as someone who joined Mahavira's Jain sangha, but became an apostate and started his own religion now called Buddhism.[52] This historic interaction is confirmed by early Buddhist texts wherein the Mahavira is called as Nigantha Nataputta.[54][55][56]

See also[edit]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ a b von Glasenapp 1925, pp. 241-242.
  2. ^ Dundas 2002, pp. 145-146, 124, 220-221.
  3. ^ a b von Glasenapp 1925, pp. 74–75.
  4. ^ Dundas 2002, p. 146.
  5. ^ Maulana Hakim Saiyid Abdul Hai "Hindustan Islami Ahad Mein" (Hindustan under Islamic rule), Eng Trans by Maulana Abdul Hasan Nadwi
  6. ^ PETERSEN, ANDREW. (2002). Dictionary of Islamic architecture. London:Routledge. ISBN 0-203-20387-9 p.241
  7. ^ PETERSEN, ANDREW. (2002). Dictionary of Islamic architecture. London:Routledge. ISBN 0-203-20387-9 p.102
  8. ^ Dundas 2002, p. 145
  9. ^ a b von Glasenapp 1925, pp. 74–75
  10. ^ Dundas 2002, p. 146
  11. ^ Dundas 2002, p. 147
  12. ^ Bhadreśvar: the oldest Islamic monuments in India. By Mehrdad Shokoohy, with contributions by Manijah Bayani-Wolpert and Natalie H. Shokoohy. (Studies in Islamic Art and Architecture. Supplements to Muqarnas, Vol. II.) Leiden, E. J. Brill, 1988, p. 7
  13. ^ (Phyllis Granoff, Speaking of Monks (Oakville, Ont.: Mosaic Press, 1992)
  14. ^ See John Cort and Phyllis Granoff's contributions in The Clever Adulteress : A Treasury of Jain Stories, (Oakville, Ont.: Mosaic Press, 1990.)
  15. ^ दिल्ली पट्ट के मूलसंघीय भट्टारक प्रभाचन्द्र और पद्मनन्दि, Parmanand Jain, Agarchand Nahta Abhinandan Granth Part 2, 1977, p.191-197
  16. ^ John E. Cort 1998, p. 86.
  17. ^ a b c Vashi, Ashish (2009-11-23). "Ahmedabad turned Akbar veggie". The Times of India. Retrieved 2009-11-23. 
  18. ^ <Jahangir's Vow of Non-Violence, Ellison B. Findley, Journal of the American Oriental Society, Vol. 107, No. 2 (Apr. - Jun., 1987), pp. 245-256
  19. ^ Akbar as Reflected in the Contemporary Jain Literature in Gujarat, Shirin Mehta, Social Scientist, Vol. 20, No. 9/10 (Sep. - Oct., 1992), pp. 54-60
  20. ^ a b c d M. S. Commissariat, ed. (1996) [1931]. Mandelslo's Travels in Western India (reprint, illustrated ed.). Asian Educational Services. pp. 101–102. ISBN 978-81-206-0714-9. 
  21. ^ Gazetteer of the Bombay Presidency: Ahmedabad. Government Central Press. 1879. p. 285. 
  22. ^ Carl Olson (2015). Indian Asceticism: Power, Violence, and Play. Oxford University Press. p. 177. ISBN 978-0-19-022533-9. 
  23. ^ von Glasenapp 1925, pp. 507-508.
  24. ^ Reynold Nicholson, A literary history of the Arabs, Charles Scribner & Sons, pages 317-324
  25. ^ a b Natana Delong-Bas (2010). The Five Pillars of Islam: Oxford Bibliographies Online Research Guide. Oxford University Press. pp. 3, 15. ISBN 978-0-19-980414-6. 
  26. ^ Dundas 2002, pp. 90–99, 104–105, 229–233.
  27. ^ a b Jaini 1998, pp. 162-165, 295-296.
  28. ^ Jeffrey M. Shaw; Timothy J. Demy (2017). War and Religion: An Encyclopedia of Faith and Conflict. ABC-CLIO. p. 635. ISBN 978-1-61069-517-6. 
  29. ^ Robert C. Solomon; Kathleen M. Higgins (1998). A Passion for Wisdom: A Very Brief History of Philosophy. Oxford University Press. pp. 11–22. ISBN 978-0-19-511209-2. 
  30. ^ Thomas R. McFaul (2006). The Future of Peace and Justice in the Global Village: The Role of the World Religions in the Twenty-first Century. Greenwood Publishing. pp. 27–40. ISBN 978-0-275-99313-9. 
  31. ^ "From the article on Tawhid in Oxford Islamic Studies Online". Oxfordislamicstudies.com. 2008-05-06. Retrieved 2014-08-24. 
  32. ^ Margaret Puskar-Pasewicz (2010). Cultural Encyclopedia of Vegetarianism. ABC-CLIO. p. 93. ISBN 978-0-313-37557-6. 
  33. ^ a b Catharina Raudvere (2014). Islam: An Introduction. I.B.Tauris. p. 198. ISBN 978-1-84885-084-2. 
  34. ^ Riaz, Mian; Chaudry, Muhammad M. (2004). Halal food production. CRC Press. pp. 1–2, 17, 195–196. ISBN 978-1-58716-029-5. 
  35. ^ Esposito, John (2011). What everyone needs to know about Islam. Oxford University Press. p. 119. ISBN 978-0-19-979413-3. 
  36. ^ a b c Jane Idelman Smith; Yvonne Yazbeck Haddad (2002). The Islamic Understanding of Death and Resurrection. Oxford University Press. pp. 23–24. ISBN 978-0-19-028880-8. 
  37. ^ a b Norman C. McClelland 2010, pp. 122-123.
  38. ^ John L. Esposito (2004). The Oxford Dictionary of Islam. Oxford University Press. pp. 137, 249. ISBN 978-0-19-975726-8. 
  39. ^ Norman L. Geisler; Abdul Saleeb (2002). Answering Islam: The Crescent in Light of the Cross. Baker Academic. p. 109. ISBN 978-0-8010-6430-2. 
  40. ^ Jaini 1998, pp. 217-236.
  41. ^ a b Dundas 2002, pp. 14–16, 102–105.
  42. ^ Jaini 1998, pp. 226-228.
  43. ^ Tara Sethia (2004). Ahimsā, Anekānta, and Jainism. Motilal Banarsidass. pp. 30–31. ISBN 978-81-208-2036-4. 
  44. ^ Dundas 2002, p. 177-180.
  45. ^ W. J. Johnson (1995). Harmless Souls: Karmic Bondage and Religious Change in Early Jainism with Special Reference to Umāsvāti and Kundakunda. Motilal Banarsidass. pp. 196–197. ISBN 978-81-208-1309-0. 
  46. ^ Spencer C. Tucker (2010). The Encyclopedia of Middle East Wars. ABC-CLIO. p. 1176. ISBN 978-1-85109-948-1. 
  47. ^ Eric O. Hanson (2006). Religion and Politics in the International System Today. Cambridge University Press. pp. 102–103. ISBN 978-0-521-61781-9. 
  48. ^ Dundas 2002, pp. 55–59, 177–182.
  49. ^ Malise Ruthven (2006). Islam in the World. Oxford University Press. p. 153. ISBN 978-0-19-530503-6.  Quote: "the famous Hadith, "there is no monasticism in Islam the monasticism (Rahbaniya) of my community is the Jihad."
  50. ^ a b c Esposito, John (2003). The Oxford dictionary of Islam. Oxford University Press. p. 22. ISBN 978-0-19-512559-7. 
  51. ^ Ali, Kecia (2008). Islam : the key concepts. Routledge. pp. 10–11. ISBN 978-0-415-39638-7. 
  52. ^ a b Dundas 2002, pp. 4-5, 120-123.
  53. ^ T.K. Tukol (1980). Jainism in South India, in Compendium of Jainism. Harvard University Archives. OCLC 8964694. 
  54. ^ Sangave 2001, p. 21.
  55. ^ Paul Dundas (2003). Jainism and Buddhism, in Buswell, Robert E. ed. Encyclopedia of Buddhism, New York: Macmillan Reference Lib. ISBN 0028657187; p. 383
  56. ^ Damien Keown; Charles S. Prebish (2013). Encyclopedia of Buddhism. Routledge. pp. 127–130. ISBN 978-1-136-98588-1. 

References[edit]