Unnecessary Fuss

Cover of the 1984 PETA film based on footage removed from the University of Pennsylvania by the Animal Liberation Front.

Unnecessary Fuss is a film produced by Ingrid Newkirk and Alex Pacheco of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), showing footage shot inside the University of Pennsylvania's Head Injury Clinic in Philadelphia.

The footage shows researchers laughing as brain damage is inflicted on baboons. It was taken from the lab by the Animal Liberation Front during a raid in May 1984. As a result of the ensuing publicity, the lab was closed down and the chief veterinarian fired.

The title of the film, Unnecessary Fuss, comes from a statement made to The Globe and Mail before the raid by the head of the clinic, neurosurgeon Dr. Thomas Gennarelli, in which he declined to describe his research because "it has the potential to stir up all sorts of unnecessary fuss."

Contents of the PETA film

The footage was shot in 1983-4 by the researchers themselves as they inflicted brain damage on baboons by slamming the apes' heads with a hydraulic device as part of their research into head injuries caused by vehicle and sports accidents. Sixty hours of audio- and video-tape were removed from the laboratory during a raid on May 28, 1984 by the ALF, who handed it over to PETA. It was subsequently edited down to 26 minutes with a voice-over commentary from Newkirk, before being distributed to the media and to Congress.

The film shows at least one sedated but not anesthetized baboon with his wrists and ankles tied, strapped to an operating table, his shaved head secured with dental cement inside a helmet. A hydraulic device known as Penn 2 slams the baboon's head from behind, pushing it forward at a 60-degree angle with a force of what the researchers said was up to 1,000 g, apparently intended to simulate whiplash (Newkirk 2000:193). [6]

After the injury is sustained, the baboon's head is dislodged from the helmet using a hammer and screwdriver. One sequence shows part of the baboon's ear being torn off along with the helmet. After pulling the baboon's head from the helmet, the researcher is heard to laugh, saying: "It's a boy," then, "Looks like I left a little ear behind."

The footage shows the researchers laughing at injured baboons, performing electrocautery on an apparently conscious baboon, smoking cigarettes and pipes during surgery, and playing loud music as the animals are injured. A researcher is seen holding a seriously injured baboon up to the camera, while others speak to the animal: "Don't be shy now, sir, nothing to be afraid of," followed by laughter, and "He says, 'you're gonna rescue me from this, aren't you? Aren't you?'," followed by more laughter.

While one baboon was being injured on the operating table by the hydraulic device, the camera panned to a brain-damaged, drooling monkey strapped into a high chair in a corner of the room, with the words "Cheerleading in the corner, we have B-10. B-10 wishes his counterpart well. As you can see, B-10 is still alive. B-10 is hoping for a good result," followed by laughter. In another sequence, one researcher is heard to say: "You better hope the ... anti-vivisection people don't get ahold of this film."

Response

The university responded that the film was a "caricature" of what had taken place in the laboratory. Shortly after the ALF raid and before PETA had released the footage, Dr. Thomas Langfitt, chief investigator at the Head Injury Clinic and chair of the University of Pennsylvania Hospital's department of neurosurgery, denied there had been abuse in the laboratory, telling the Philadelphia Daily News that the animals had been treated humanely and that "[r]esearchers would never laugh at the apes. We treat the baboons the way we treat human beings."

A subsequent investigation by eighteen veterinarians from the American College of Laboratory Animal Medicine, commissioned by the Office for Protection from Research Risks (OPRR), agreed that the PETA film had "grossly overstated" the deficiencies in the Head Injury Clinic, but after a three-day sit-in by animal-rights activists at the National Institutes for Health, and the personal intervention of Margaret Heckler, then Health and Human Services secretary, the government concluded that the "extraordinarily serious violations" [7] seen on the footage were sufficient to justify the clinic's closure.

The violations included that the depth of anesthetic coma was "questionable," that most of the animals were not seen by a veterinarian either before or after surgery, survival surgical techniques were not carried out in the required aseptic manner, that the operating theater was not properly cleaned, and that smoking was allowed in the operating theater despite the presence of oxygen tanks. The OPPR also found deficiencies in many other laboratories operated by the university. The university's chief veterinarian was fired, new training programs were initiated, and the university was placed on probation, with quarterly progress reports to OPRR required. [8] [9]

Criticism of the PETA film

When PETA made its 26-minute film available, the OPRR initially refused to investigate because the film had been edited from 60 hours of videotape. For over a year PETA refused to release the original footage. When they eventually handed over the unedited material, the OPRR discovered that the footage of the brain damage being inflicted involved just one baboon out of the 150 who had received the Penn 2 injuries. The film gave the impression that the brain-damage scenes involved several animals. [10] The OPRR identified 25 errors in Newkirk's voice-over commentary. One example was where an accidental water spill over a conscious baboon during a surgical procedure was identified, without evidence, as an acid spill. [11]

See also

• Animal Liberation Front
• Britches
• People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals
• Pit of despair
• Primate experimentation at Cambridge University
• Silver Spring Monkeys

References

• Unnecessary Fuss 1, UN2, UN3, UN4, UN5, the video composed of footage taken from the lab by the ALF
• McCarthy, Charles. R. "Reflections on the Organizational Locus of the Office for Protection from Research Risks", The Online Ethics Center for Engineering and Science at Case Western Reserve University, undated, retrieved February 26, 2006
• Newkirk, Ingrid. Free the Animals. Lantern Books, 2000. ISBN 1-930051-22-0
• Newkirk, Ingrid & Pacheco, Alex. Unnecessary Fuss, video, 26 minutes, available from PETA. [12]
• Sideris, Lisa, McCarthy, Charles, & Smith, David H. "Roots of Concern with Nonhuman Animals in Biomedical Ethics", Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Journal, V40(1) 1999.

Further reading

• The Primate Freedom Project