Welfare of farmed insects
- 1 Debate over the issue's significance
- 2 Welfare considerations for rearing
- 3 Slaughter methods
- 4 Farmed insects not used for protein
- 5 See also
- 6 Notes
Debate over the issue's significance
Scientists remain uncertain about the existence and degree of pain in invertebrates, including insects. Nonetheless, insect welfare is being taken increasingly seriously in laboratory settings. Vincent Wigglesworth suggested a precautionary approach of anaesthetizing insects during potentially painful procedures. John Cooper has written about techniques for "Anesthesia, analgesia, and euthanasia of invertebrates" including insects. Neil A. C. Bennie and colleagues proposed a method for chemical euthanasia of insects and other terrestrial arthropods.
Some authors have begun extending discussions of insect welfare beyond the laboratory to the domain of raising insects for food. A new Dutch Animal Act that went into effect on 1 January 2013 creates a regulatory framework for farm-animal welfare based on the five freedoms, and the law specifically lists a number of insect species as "production animals" whose wellbeing needs to be respected. Dutch politician Marianne Thieme asked a series of questions suggesting concern that insect farming would multiply the number of animals farmed and killed for human consumption. Robert Nathan Allen of the pro-entomophagy organization Little Herds feels that the welfare of insects is important, though he believes well managed farms can maintain high standards of care. Some entomophagy suppliers highlight the importance of humane insect treatment. For instance, World Ento uses the name "Good Karma Killing" to describe its process of freezing insects into a statis state. A 2013 FAO report on "Edible insects" includes a section encouraging high standards of welfare in entomophagy operations, despite uncertainty about whether insects can suffer.
Others feel that considering the wellbeing of farmed insects is going too far. Rhys Southan suggests that even most vegans do not care a lot about insects, but that "Insects are to animal rights what Larry Flynt is to the First Amendment – you have to uphold their rights even if you don’t want to, or the whole thing falls apart." He goes on to propose satirical slogans that insect-rights activists might use against entomophagy. Wesley J. Smith rejects a proposal that "We have to begin to ponder the welfare of insects we consume," adding: "See how crazy things get once human exceptionalism is rejected?" Smith cites a parody website, "The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Insects." The site features an article feigning concern for the insects eaten alive by contestants on Survivor.
Welfare considerations for rearing
Because there is little standardized protocol for insect rearing, most farmers learn the best production methods by trial and error. For instance, if they kill an insect colony by setting the temperature too high, they avoid doing that in the future. Most breeders keep their techniques secret in order to avoid having them copied by other farms.
Because there are so many types of insects, it is not feasible to devise a single protocol for their treatment. Case-by-case understanding is required.
When viruses infect an insect-rearing facility, they spread rapidly and kill most of the insects.
Humans can spread diseases to farmed insects. Thus, sanitation is very important, and only farm staff should have access to the insects. For instance, the company Van de Ven had a pathogen outbreak that killed all of its Zophobas morio worms, and the breeders hypothesized that the disease may have been brought by human visitors.
Insects are poikilothermic, but maintaining an adequate temperature range remains important. For example, mealworms thrive best when living close together, but this can lead to overheating if temperature is not controlled.
Some insects like locusts begin eating each other when they become overcrowded or malnourished. Adequate space and nutrition are important to prevent this.
- Termites are either eaten alive directly where they're found or are brought home to be roasted over coals or fried.
- Cicadas are boiled, fried, or sautéed.
- Water bugs may be eaten whole, steamed, fried, or roasted and canned.
- Scorpions are skewered alive and fried in oil.
- Tarantulas are fried in oil or roasted over a fire.
Little research has been done on humane methods of killing insects for consumption.
The most common killing methods used by entomophagy companies in the Netherlands are freezing and dry-freezing (i.e., freezing and reducing pressure in order to extract water from the insects).
Protix Biosystems kills its black soldier flies by shredding, since its end product is a powder. Death takes less than a second. Tarique Arsiwalla at Protix said shredding makes sense because Western consumers are more likely to accept powdered insects than whole insects.
The Jagran company has tried asphyxiation, cooling, freeze-drying, boiling, and shredding. Managing Director Walter Jansen believes that shredding is most humane.
The Kreca company kills its animal-feed insects by putting them into a fridge or freeze-drying them. Insects destined for human consumption are first sterilized in hot water and then are refrigerated or freeze-dried.
FAO's "Edible insects" report suggests: "Insect-killing methods that would reduce suffering include freezing or instantaneous techniques such as shredding."
While freezing is sometimes said to be a humane way to kill certain arthropods, others dispute this. According to "AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals," freezing is "not considered to be humane" when not preceded by another form of anesthesia. The British and Irish Association of Zoos and Aquariums (BIAZA) Terrestrial Invertebrate Working Group (TIWG) reports on a survey conducted by Mark Bushell of BIAZA institutions. He found that refrigeration and freezing were the most common methods "of euthanasia of invertebrates although research has suggested that this is probably one of the least ethical options." That said, freezing is a worst-case method if chemical or instantaneous physical destruction is not possible.
Some "how to" guides for eating insects make no mention of freezing or other euthanasia methods. For example, Miles Olson recommends
- suffocating or roasting ants
- decapitating, gutting, and then stewing, roasting, or sautéing slugs
- steaming and slicing snails
- frying, roasting, toasting, suffocating, or drowning crickets
- drowning, squeezing, and then stir frying or stewing earthworms
- eating aphids raw
and so on.
The website Insects Are Food suggests refrigerating insects to slow them down without killing them, prior to boiling or otherwise cooking them.
Other guides recommend freezing first. Timothy Ferriss recounts what he observed when roasted his insects without freezing them first: "Suffice it to say, merely sedated crickets make horrible noises if you roast them, and the visual is far, far worse. Do yourself a favor and freeze them."
Live insect feed
Sometimes insects are not killed by farming companies but are sold live, for consumption by fish and pets. 95% of the Kreca company's insects are sold live. Of the 1500 kg per week of mealworms produced by the Van de Ven company, most are sold as live feed.
Many suppliers of insects for reptiles offer live bugs and worms. Monitor lizards are typically fed live insects and may not eat pre-killed ones. Amphibians typically require live insects—wild-caught, home-grown, or bought at a pet store—although some like axolotls can be fed chunks of meat. It's generally hard to convert reptiles and amphibians that eat insects to pre-killed prey, though some pet owners can feed dead insects by moving or dangling them. Bearded dragons can be fed dead crickets by hiding them in other food, dangling them with tongs, squirting them with water, or vibrating a bowl.
Live worms and insects are commonly used as fishing bait, with the result that they are either eaten alive by fish or drowned.
Farmed insects not used for protein
Shellac is produced from a resin secreted by the lac bug on specific trees in Asia. In addition to its use in industry, shellac is incorporated into some fruits, coffee beans, and candies as confectioner's glaze. Some vegans avoid confectioner's glaze because lac bugs may be killed during shellac production. Lac used to produce red dye may be even more injurious to lac bugs because while shellac comes from lac-bug secretions, lac dye's color comes from the insect bodies themselves.
- Smith, Jane A. (1991). "A Question of Pain in Invertebrates". ILAR Journal. 33 (1–2): 25–31. doi:10.1093/ilar.33.1-2.25.
- Sherwin, C.M. (2001). "Can invertebrates suffer? Or, how robust is argument-by-analogy?". Animal Welfare (supplement). 10: 103–118.
- Wigglesworth, Vincent B. (1980). "Do insects feel pain?". Antenna: 8–9.
- Cooper, John E. (2011). "Anesthesia, analgesia, and euthanasia of invertebrates". ILAR Journal. 52 (2): 196–204. doi:10.1093/ilar.52.2.196.
- Bennie, Neil A. C.; Christopher D. Loaring; Mikaella M. G. Bennie; Steven A. Trim (2012). "An effective method for terrestrial arthropod euthanasia". Journal of Experimental Biology. 215: 4237–4241. doi:10.1242/jeb.074997. PMID 22996446.
- Erens, Jesse; Es van, Sam; Haverkort, Fay; Kapsomenou, Eleni; Luijben, Andy (2012). "A bug's life: Large-scale insect rearing in relation to animal welfare" (PDF). Wageningen University. Retrieved 13 May 2014.
- De Goede, D. M.; J. Erens; E. Kapsomenou; M. Peters (2013). "Large scale insect rearing and animal welfare". In Helena Röcklinsberg, Per Sandin. The ethics of consumption: The citizen, the market and the law. Wageningen Academic Publishers. pp. 236–242. ISBN 978-90-8686-784-4.
- Thieme, Marianne (12 Oct 2012). "Questions about insects as a protein source for pig and chicken feed". Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- King, Barbara J. (3 April 2014). "The Joys And Ethics Of Insect Eating". Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- "Current Products and Prices". World Ento. 22 Oct 2013. Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- Arnold van Huis; Joost Van Itterbeeck; Harmke Klunder; Esther Mertens; Afton Halloran; Giulia Muir; Paul Vantomme (2013). "5.6. Animal Welfare". Edible insects: Future prospects for food and feed security (PDF). Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. p. 65. ISBN 978-92-5-107596-8. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Southan, Rhys (18 March 2010). "The Vegan Response to the Insect Eating Movement?". Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- Smith, Wesley J. (28 April 2014). "Don't Hurt the Insects!". National Review Online. Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- "The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Insects". 2006. Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- "Latest - Reality TV causes untold suffering". 2006. Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- Ouedraogo, R. M.; M. S. Goettel; J. Brodeur (2004). "Behavioral thermoregulation in the migratory locust: a therapy to overcome fungal infection". Oecologia. 138 (2): 312–319. doi:10.1007/s00442-003-1431-0.
- Greenfield, Beth (21 Oct 2011). "15 Insects You Won't Believe Are Edible". Budget Travel. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Weiner, Miriam B. (28 Apr 2011). "Countries That Eat Bugs". U.S. News & World Report. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Lara (6 Mar 2013). "Eating Insects in Thailand". Travel in Thailand. Archived from the original on 19 Jan 2014. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- "Euthanizing Insects". Colorado Plateau Biodiversity Center. 6 Aug 2012. Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- Pizzi, Romain (2012). "Spiders". In Gregory A. Lewbart. Invertebrate Medicine (2nd ed.). Wiley-Blackwell. p. 211. ISBN 978-0813817583.
- Cornelia Gunkel; Gregory A. Lewbart (2007). "13. Invertebrates". In Gary West; Darryl Heard; Nigel Caulkett. Zoo Animal & Wildlife Immobilization and Anesthesia. Blackwell. pp. 147–158. ISBN 978-0-8138-2566-3.
- "AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals: 2013 Edition" (PDF). American Veterinary Medical Association. p. 76. Retrieved 12 May 2014.
- Sarah Pellett; Romain Pizzi; Steven Trim; Mark Bushell; Dave Clarke; Jamie Wood (Apr 2013). BIAZA Recommendations for Ethical Euthanasia of Invertebrates (1.1 ed.). British and Irish Association of Zoos and Aquariums.
- Olson, Miles (2012). "22. Exploring Entomophagy: Bugs as Food". Unlearn, Rewild: Earth Skills, Ideas and Inspiration for the Future Primitive. New Society Publishers. pp. 193–202. ISBN 978-0865717213.
- "IAF Frequently Asked Questions". Insects Are Food. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Price, Aletheia. "Eating Bugs!". Retrieved 31 May 2014.
- Tarantola, Andrew (16 Sep 2013). "Why, How, and Where You Should Start Eating Bugs". Gizmodo. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Ferriss, Timothy (2012). The 4-Hour Chef: The Simple Path to Cooking Like a Pro, Learning Anything, and Living the Good Life. New Harvest. ISBN 978-0547884592.
- "Livefoods Direct Ltd - Britain's Foremost Supplier Of Livefoods". Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- "Reptilefood.com". Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- "Timberline Live Pet Food". Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- "The Monitor FAQ--Feeding". Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- "Keeping Frogs!". New Zealand Frogs. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Kaplan, Melissa (1 Jan 2014). "Feeding Prekilled vs. Live Prey". Melissa Kaplan's Herp and Green Iguana Information Collection. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- "Pre-killed feeding?". Frog Forum. 3–5 June 2010. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Team, Ben. "How to Get Bearded Dragons to Eat Canned Crickets". PawNation. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Linda. "Feeder insects for your predatory insects". Keeping Insects. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Dick, Gail. "Insects a La Carte". Hedgehog Headquarters. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- "Is Carmine Vegan?". Is It Vegan?. 10 Mar 2011. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Shreeves, Robin (24 Apr 2012). "What is carmine and why is Starbucks taking it out of its products?". Mother Nature Network. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Yacoubou, Jeanne (2 Jan 2013). "Alternatives to Insect-Derived Food Colors". Vegetarian Resource Group Blog. Retrieved 1 June 2014.
- Yacoubou, Jeanne (30 Nov 2010). "Q & A on Shellac". Vegetarian Resource Group. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
- Flinn, Angel (15 Aug 2011). "Shellac & Food Glaze". Gentle World. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
- Green, C. L. (1995). "5: Insect Dyes". Non-Wood Forest Products 4: Natural colourants and dyestuffs. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Retrieved 3 July 2014.