Death of Jill Phipps
|Date||1 February 1995(aged 31)|
|Location||Baginton, Warwickshire, England|
Background of protests
In 1994, animal rights protesters in England had convinced the major ferries (P & O, Stena Sealink, and Brittany Ferries) to stop live animal exports. In January 1995, a group of thirty farmers established an organization (ITF) to acquire alternative transportation through sea and air ports. One such pathway was air exports via Coventry Airport. Protesters had successfully pressured Coventry, Plymouth and Dover officials to ban the exports, but all were ordered by the courts to permit them.[a]
When exports resumed in early January 1995 via the port in Shoreham, Sussex, a mob of 500–600 protesters "blocked the roads, damaged the lorries and were violent to the drivers and the police" which succeeded in stopping sea exports for a few days, until authorities added over 1,000 policemen to escort the convoys. Policing costs exceeded ₤6 million and 20,000 man-hours, and the Chief Constable of Sussex declared they would only support the ports two days a week and that they would prevent passage of lorries on the other days. These quantitative restrictions were challenged in court and it was "concluded that the unlawful activity of protesters and its effects on police resources provided no justification for totally prohibiting a lawful trade."
More court wranglings followed, but in the end the trade was ended in 1996 when most of the European Economic Community boycotted British beef due to an outbreak of mad cow disease. In 2006 this ban was lifted, but Coventry Airport's executive chairman pledged that he would refuse requests to fly live calves.
On 1 February 1995, Phipps was one of 35 protesters at Coventry Airport in Baginton, protesting the export of live calves to Amsterdam for distribution across Europe. Ten protesters broke through police lines and were trying to bring the lorry to a halt by sitting in the road or chaining themselves to it when Phipps was crushed beneath the lorry's wheels; her fatal injuries included a broken spine.
"An hour after she arrived on the day she died, the lorry appeared. Most of the protesters were further down the road but a small group, including Ms Phipps who had arrived earlier, were at the entrance of the airport when the articulated lorry came up the road. As it bypassed the main group of campaigners, she ran, arms outstretched, headlong towards it. She clambered up the front wing. Her sister watched in horror as she slipped and fell beneath the wheels."
The Crown Prosecution Service ruled there was no evidence to bring any charges against the driver. Phipps' family blamed the police for her death because the police were working to keep the convoy of lorries moving. The inquest heard that the driver may have been distracted by a protester running into the road ahead of him, who was being removed by a policeman. A verdict of accidental death was returned.
For many years, animal rights protests were held around the anniversary date of Phipps' death, and many have claimed Phipps was a martyr to the cause. Though Phipps had been quoted as saying "Yes, I think people could be hurt ... We are so determined to stop this trade, we will go that far," her father said "Jill was no martyr to the cause. She had a young son to live for. She did not want to die." Jill's Film, with footage of Phipps, the Coventry protests, the funeral, and interviews with Phipps' family was produced, and shown for the first time at the Jill's Day 2007 event in Coventry.
Jill Phipps (15 January 1964 – 1 February 1995) left school at the age of 16 and went to work for the Royal Mail. She had become interested in caring for animals when young, and joined her mother's campaigning against the fur trade from the age of 11. After herself becoming a vegetarian, Phipps persuaded the rest of her family to join her. Phipps joined the Eastern Animal Liberation League, and a local campaign Phipps and her mother took part in resulted in pressuring a local fur shop and fur farm to close down.
In 1986, together with her mother and sister, Phipps raided the Unilever laboratories in objection of their practice of vivisection, and "smashed computer equipment, causing thousands of pounds worth of damage". The group was caught and prosecuted: Phipps' mother was sentenced to six months imprisonment, her sister to eighteen months, but Phipps herself received a suspended sentence as she was pregnant.
After her son was born, Phipps spent less time protesting, attending occasional demonstrations and hunt sabotage meetings with her young son. The use of Coventry airport for export of veal calves horrified her, and in January 1995 she walked almost 100 miles from Coventry to Westminster to protest. On her 31st birthday she protested outside the home of the man who ran Phoenix Aviation, the firm that operated the exports from Coventry airport.
- "It is the fear of unlawful disruption which has prompted Coventry and Dover to refuse the trade (Coventry's ban being subject to the court first lifting the injunction requiring it at present to accept the trade); and which prompts Plymouth City Council to seek a similar ban. All three authorities, let it be clear at once, expressly now disavow animal welfare considerations as any part of their motivation (although earlier it was otherwise with both Coventry and Plymouth City Councils)."
- "Regina v Coventry Airport Ex Parte Phoenix Aviation; Regina v Dover Harbour Board Ex Parte Gilder: QBD 12 Apr 1995". 20 March 2019. Archived from the original on 17 July 2020. Retrieved 16 July 2020.
- "R v Coventry Airport & Anor ex p. Phoenix Aviation & Ors  EWHC 1 (Admin) (12 April 1995)". www.bailii.org. Archived from the original on 8 November 2017. Retrieved 16 July 2020.
- Barnard, Catherine; Hare, Ivan (1997). "The Right to Protest and the Right to Export: Police Discretion and the Free Movement of Goods". The Modern Law Review. pp. 394–411 – via JSTOR.
- Darnton, John (28 March 1996). "Europe Orders Ban on Exports Of British Beef". Archived from the original on 16 July 2020. Retrieved 16 July 2020 – via NYTimes.com.
- Coventry Live (9 March 2006). "No veal flights from Coventry". Coventry Telegraph. Archived from the original on 15 July 2020. Retrieved 13 July 2020.
- Honigsbaum, Mark (5 February 2005). "Woman who died in veal protest becomes martyr of wider cause". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 15 July 2020. Retrieved 13 July 2020.
- Valley, Paul (3 February 1995). "For what cause did Jill Phipps die?". The Independent. Archived from the original on 10 November 2017. Retrieved 29 October 2017.
- Day, Rosie (30 January 2015). "Jill Phipps". Coventry Telegraph. Archived from the original on 15 July 2020. Retrieved 13 July 2020.
- Griffin, Mary (31 January 2015). "Coventry campaigner Jill Phipps remembered 20 years after her death". Coventry Telegraph. Archived from the original on 25 March 2019. Retrieved 13 July 2020.
- Coventry Live (7 February 2006). "Friend's movie tribute to tragic Jill". Coventry Telegraph. Archived from the original on 14 July 2020. Retrieved 13 July 2020.
- "Jill's Film". Jill Phipps Memorial Website. Archived from the original on 2 March 2007.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Jill Phipps.|