Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Countering systemic bias/open tasks: Difference between revisions

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
m →Requests for expansion: When is a week ago
Line 620: Line 620:
=== Requests for review ===
=== Requests for review ===


*[[Debt-based monetary system]]
**[[Debt money]]
**[[Debt-free money]]
* [[Behavioral finance]]
* [[Behavioral finance]]
* [[Commodity markets]] -- should mention UN proposals for new ways to use such to create [[fair trade]].
* [[Commodity markets]] -- should mention UN proposals for new ways to use such to create [[fair trade]].

Revision as of 21:32, 29 December 2007

Shortcut

These are the open tasks for the Wikiproject Countering systemic bias. Articles are listed thematically, and then by the type of assistance requested. An article stub for a feminist author would thus be found under the "Requests for expansion" section under Women's Studies.

Themes are divided into four stages: non-existent, stubby, identifiably flawed and satisfactory. "Requested articles" are pages that are entirely missing from Wikipedia. A little bit of research on the web is normally enough to write a stub. Be sure to move the list entry to the relevant section once you are done. Articles that are stubby, or otherwise lacking in content, may be found under "Requests for expansion". If something in particular is missing, such as a university article with a long list of alumni but little historical background, be sure to say so when you enter it. "Requests for review" is for articles that are of decent length but need more attention. A need for a copyedit or for a fact check by a knowledgeable reader are appropriate reasons to ask for review.

Once an article has passed through the various stages of this process it may be placed under the Satisfactory section. Satisfactory articles are well-rounded, long enough to cover the topic in reasonable detail, and lack any major flaws. They are not expected to be perfect.

This open tasks list is intended to be a complement to the various Wikipedia features such as Cleanup, Requests for expansion, Pages needing attention and peer review, and you are encouraged to add articles from this list to those pages. Many articles on this page may also be good candidates for Collaboration of the week or the Article improvement drive. If you find a particularly good article in a CSB-related area, by all means nominate it as a Featured Article candidate.

If you feel an article is neglected due to systemic bias, feel free to add it to an appropriate section or even to start a new section below. Sections describing perceived biases that do not include articles are placed at the bottom of the page. If no articles are placed within the section within a month, it will be assumed that the objection is not actionable and the section will be removed.

Add this table to your userpage using the following: {{WikiProjectCSBTasks}}

Geography

File:Bias map small.jpg
Most neglected countries
Logo for Countries section of Countering systemic bias
Logo for Countries section of Countering systemic bias

Wikipedia has major holes in its geographic coverage primarily in Africa, but also Asia and South America.

Countries for improvement

The countries below have been identified as those most in need of work. They are accompanied by some online resources that may be useful in contributing to the articles. If a user feels that a country article has progressed to the level where it may be replaced by another, please seek consensus on the talk page.

  1. Benin (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Porto-Novo, Cotonou
  2. Burkina Faso (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Ouagadougou
  3. Burundi (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Bujumbura
  4. Cameroon (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Yaoundé
  5. Central African Republic (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Bangui
  6. Chad (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), N'Djamena
  7. Comoros (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Moroni, Comoros
  8. Democratic Republic of the Congo (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Kinshasa
  9. Republic of the Congo (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Brazzaville
  10. Côte d'Ivoire (see Category, BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Yamoussoukro
  11. The Gambia (see Category BBC profile timeline, HRW, google search images news), Banjul
  12. Georgia (see Category), Tbilisi
  13. Guinea (see Category), Conakry
  14. Guinea-Bissau (see Category), Bissau
  15. Kyrgyzstan (see Category), Bishkek
  16. Madagascar (see Category), Antananarivo
  17. Malawi (see Category), Lilongwe, Blantyre, Malawi
  18. Mali (see Category), Bamako
  19. Mozambique (see Category), Maputo
  20. Myanmar (see Category), Yangon
  21. Niger (see Category); Niamey
  22. Papua New Guinea (see Category), Port Moresby
  23. Suriname (see Category), Paramaribo
  24. Tajikistan (see Category), Dushanbe
  25. Tanzania (see Category), Dar-es-Salaam
  26. Togo (see Category), Lomé
  27. Turkmenistan (see Category), Ashgabat
  28. Western Sahara (see Category), Laayoune

Translations of any appropriate articles in the French or Portuguese Wikipedia can be requested on Wikipedia:Translation into English - though some articles are actually shorter in the foreign language version. For materials not in Wikipedia, but available in electronic form, you could contact an appropriate individual at Wikipedia:Translators available.

Missing geography articles

The following articles are about important geographical regions in the non-English-speaking world.

  1. Shuozhou (in China)
  2. Zambezi Escarpment (in Zimbabwe)

Rename problems

There's yet another attempt to replace Java with a disambiguation page... See Talk:Java for the discussion - it's amazing how many people think a programming language can be even remotely comparable in notability to an island with a population of 120 million. -- Danny Yee 03:06, 29 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Are you mad? So you say that programing languages are not important? Java CAN mean either the island, OR the coffee made there, OR the programming language, SO it should be a DISAMBIG page. --Rev

Lets put this in context, what would your reaction be if the main page for an an article entitled "Kentucky" was for the fried chicken, with the rifle and horse race coming in front of the State on a disambiguation page. The fact is the place came first and those other things were named for it. To give those subsequent topics equal billing, is to put the cart before the horse and to show a lack of perspective. The fact is the island and nation of Java existed first, without the island there would be no Java coffee, and with no Java coffee a group of software engineers would have had another favourite beverage to name their project.Koonan the almost civilised 00:58, 8 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Colonialism

Maybe making a Wikiproject would be a good idea? Loads of work to do: Decolonization (only charts and lists, no text) Decolonization of Africa, Colonialism, New Imperialism (all the serie), Long Depression (connected to New Imperialism), etc. etc. Try to find a way to organize all the resources on colonialism so it is easy to acceed (some people couldn't find Scramble for Africa!), especially relating to the question of three main articles: colonialism, colonization and colony, which should at least be transformed into two main articles (one for European colonialism, 15th century onwards, and other for all types of colonization - Roman colonization, space colonization, etc.). This also goes, of course, for neocolonialism and postcolonialism and all Developing countries' debt related issues and economical policies. Lapaz 14:06, 30 May 2006 (UTC)[reply]

I think you are totally correct. I don't think I'll have time to help you on this, at least not in the foreseeable future, but I think it would make a great WikiProject. - Jmabel | Talk 17:26, 12 June 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Please also take a look at articles involving the annexation of Hawai'i, such as Liliʻuokalani, Blount Report, Morgan Report, and the so-called Republic of Hawaiʻi set up by wealthy white pro-annexation forces. There's been a single-handed attempt to fashion out of thin air validity in the last two articles, with references to sites set up by that same wikipedia contributor! Huangdi 10:52, 9 September 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Mahalo, the references to the http://morganreport.org site are simply in the same spirit of the UH annexation documents, who were unable to finish digitizing the Morgan Report due to a major flood that interrupted their work (they provide a link to the http://morganreport.org site as well). The report is there in its entirety, with original scanned images available for verification that the digital text is accurate. The question as to what reports are valid or not may be disputed by pro-hawaiian sovereignty activists, but my work has been specifically to counter the systemic bias that had ignored important parts of the historical record. For example, Huangdi added a sentence, "The charge by Native Hawaiians that the overthrow was illegal persisted, covertly at first for years, but then openly during the so-called "Hawaiian Renaissance". With no citation whatsoever to the "covert" charge, this kind of baseless assertion has been frankly common in the pro-sovereignty articles here for quite some time. Of course, being "covert" means of course they wouldn't be able to find any citations (how could they, if everyone was keeping it secret?) - I suppose one could also add the sentence, "The acceptance of Native Hawaiians that the overthrow was not caused by the U.S., and that Statehood was desireable persisted, openly at first for years, but then only covertly since the so-called "Hawaiian Renaissance". I would love to have a third-party look at the articles, though, and help building up proper citations. If Huangdi would like to help systematically go through the articles in question with me, I'd be more than happy to address specific issues he may have. --JereKrischel 02:27, 11 September 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Developing World

All aspects of the "developing world", primarily in Africa, but also Asia and South America.

Requested articles

See also: Wikipedia:List of missing Africa topics, Wikipedia:List of missing Middle Eastern topics, Wikipedia:List of missing Oceania topics, List of conflicts in Africa
Here are some tasks awaiting attention:

Current and recent events

Events and people recently or currently in the news that may need updates

Requests for expansion

Request for review/attention

Seems to have been fixed adequately for a little while now. --Dpr 06:22, 9 November 2005 (UTC)[reply]

Featured article candidates and peer review

Art and Design

Requested articles

  • Beauty myth, a review of Western ideals of corporeal beauty, how that contrasts with those of other cultures, and effects of acculturation. -- I moved the article that was there on the Naomi Wolf book to The Beauty Myth. Beauty myth now redirects there. The blue link here should not be taken to mean that someone has started an article on the concept apart from Wolf's book. Jkelly 07:43, 23 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]

Requests for expansion

See also: Category:Art stubs, Category:Artist stubs, Category:Art organization stubs, Pages needing attention/Culture and Arts

Requests for review/attention


Women's studies

Logo for Female-oriented section of Countering systemic bias
Logo for Female-oriented section of Countering systemic bias

Female oriented subjects - Feminism, Women authors, professions with high proportion of women etc

Requested articles

Requests for expansion

Requests for review/attention

  • Systematic silencing of so called "problematic" points of view in articles on or in articles related to Women's studies, gender and other feminism-related articles. Prominent feminist whistleblowers, feminist dissidents, scientists and other non-feminist points of view are being censored when they oppose the 'gender' feminist "party line". Much pandering to politically correct but blatantly gynocentric propaganda points but rarely is balanced non-sexist research common in these articles. 128.111.95.245 02:49, 11 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Oriana Fallaci prominent Italian journalist and author. Little though I like her remarks on contemporary Islam, she certainly deserves more of an article. We mostly have a bibliography, quotations, and links. -- Jmabel 22:59, Sep 23, 2004 (UTC)
  • Category:Modernist women writers

Non-English language literature

Non-English language literature (particularly writers whose work is unavailable or not widely available in English). See also List of African writers.

Requested articles

These include all of the nonexistent links listed under "Literature by country or language"

Requests for expansion

Satisfactory

Wikipedia:WikiProject Countering systemic bias open tasks/Linguistics

Agriculture and horticultural studies

Agriculture etc
Agriculture etc

Agricultural and horticultural studies. Not typically a 'geek' concern, especially outside of botany as such.

Requested articles

Requests for expansion

Requests for review/attention

  • Farmer - modern and Western (esp. US) bias, nothing on pre-modern farming, farming in the rest of the world
  • Slaughterhouse -- Some debiasing is done. Global and historical persp. needed
  • Food science
  • Dairy science
  • Meat science
  • Wool -- the current article is about sheep wool, rather than an overview, while limited information about alpaca wool is relegated to the alpaca article, and other animals such as goats are merely mentioned as alternative sources.
  • Threshing-board - great job recently done translating this from Spanish, but inevitably it show a Spanish/Iberian bias in terminology, coverage, selection of sources, etc. It's a featured article in Spanish, and it's easy to see why, but it will takes some work to get it there in English. - 19:06, 28 December 2006 (UTC)

Ethnic minorities

Under-represented ethnic minorities in the developed world etc. (and other related topics)

Requested articles

General

  • Venda people
  • The Long Road to Freedom: 5 CD compilation of "the heritage of enslaved Africans"; Harry Belafonte started this project in 1961, it was completed only in 2001. Our article on Belafonte mentions it only in passing; I also found a mention of it in Daniel Brown, "Songs of Slavery", Index on Censorship, Volume 36, Number 1, 2007, p. 138–140, but not enough to write from. If someone is familiar with this collection, we should certainly have an article. - Jmabel | Talk 20:56, 4 June 2007 (UTC)[reply]

American Indian biographies:

African American biographies:

Basic version complete --Dpr 05:01, 10 November 2005 (UTC)[reply]
Even featured on Did You Know (10 November 2005) --Dpr 05:43, 11 November 2005 (UTC)[reply]

Requests for expansion

Requests for review/attention

  • NABJ Hall of Fame is probably OK as it stands, but full of red links that could be followed up. Leading African-American journalists past and present. - Jmabel|Talk 18:04, Oct 14, 2004 (UTC)
  • White supremacy deals almost entirely with contemporary, marginal groups and does not discuss white supremacy as a domininant ideology beginning with the period of European expansion and continuing at least well into the 20th century. -- Jmabel | Talk 20:02, Mar 21, 2005 (UTC)
  • Young Lords New York area Puerto Rican semi-gang, semi-political-party circa 1970, moved at least for a while towards trying to become a Puerto Rican equivalent of the Black Panthers. I got this one started: there is a lot of online material & probably more elsewhere. Expect sources to somewhat contradict one another. This would be a great topic for a good researcher who understands how to cite sources, etc. - Jmabel 23:19, Oct 4, 2004 (UTC)
  • Zoroastrianism, Zoroaster and related topics all suffer from serious neglect, bias and misinformation. Someone has even categorized "Zoroastrian gods" -- despite the fact that it is a monotheistic religion -- including listing Ahriman in that category. This is equivalent to listing Satan as a "Christian God"! Zosodada 20:22, 22 Jan 2005 (UTC)
  • Aramaic-speaking Christian groups: Syriacs, Aramaeans, Assyrian, Chaldeans, Assyro-Chaldeans. These are quite a mess, as ethnic definitions are not very clear, and all of these labels have political connotations.
  • Latitude -- dubious section on "Evolutionary explanations" futurebird 14:38, 27 January 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Norouz and Kurdish celebration of Newroz. The old Zoroastrian new year, celebrated by Persians, Kurds and other groups in the region. One ethnic group, not surprising the by far largest, seems though to be very dominant in the coverage. Bertilvidet 13:33, 10 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Labor issues

labor
labor

Labor related issues. See also Wikipedia:WikiProject Organized Labour.



Here are some tasks awaiting attention:

Requested articles

Requests for expansion

Requests for review/attention

  • Bill Haywood Important leader in the IWW in the early 20th century. I've made a to-do list; once these items are addressed, I plan on putting it in for peer review and eventually pursuing featured article status. I've pretty much been the sole contributor to this article for quite some time, so any help would be greatly appreciated! --JerryOrr 21:41, 31 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Limited geographic scope

Limited geographic scope
Limited geographic scope

Most of the articles listed on Open Tasks are neglected because of their subject matter. The articles below are internally biased. In other words, they currently deal only with matters in certain countries, and/or often have a U.S. or developed country perspective rather than a global one. Once they have been edited to remove the geographic bias, please place them in the Satisfactory section.

A-M

  • Adoption Lacks perspective of countries that are the sources of international adoption.
  • Interracial adoption is solely from a U.S. perspective, is from a white adoptive family perspective, and lacks information on international adoptions (which can in some cases also be considered interracial).
  • Beekeeping Has been a subsistence method from time immemorial for some societies. Article makes it almost look like a Western hobbyist practice.
  • Bimetallism Deals almost exclusively with bimetallism in U.S. history; could use information on Islamic bimetallism and any other non-US historical/modern examples that may exist. Another editor removed {globalize/USA} tag when I added it to the article (twice) but raises no objection to having the tag on the talk page. --Eloil 22:40, 22 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Bomb disposal This article is heavily anglo-centric. Other definitions of domain terminology (e.g. Explosive Ordnance Disposal) is also American. Drdan 18:06, 9 April 2006 (UTC) - It was invented by the British, and refined to where it is today by the Americans. There hasn't been significant additions by other countries because most of the second and third world countries today send their Technicians to UK or US schools for training. It's not a topic many can speak about with authority. What about a topic that has systemic bias because it is monosystemic in nature? Shawn 11:42 15 April 2006 (EDT)[reply]
  • Breakfast Scant references to non-western practices. Much added on Latin America, Asia and the Middle East. Still lacking anything on Africa.
  • Cannabis rescheduling is unashamedly about various bits of legislation in the USA, and has nothing to say on Cannabis legislation anywhere else. Gareth Hughes 18:21, 16 Feb 2005 (UTC)
  • CFL - This redirect page goes to Canadian Football League which is of interest to Canadians. The rest of the world is probably interested in CFL (disambiguation). CFL(disambiguation)]] should be moved to CFL. It has been discussed a few times at Talk:CFL (disambiguation)Alan Liefting 06:56, 16 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Cyber-bullying Seems as if that only occurs in the United States, United Kingdom, and Australia. Johnny Au 18:00, 29 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Civilian control of the military I'm in the process of expanding this article but will be the first one to admit that my examples and structure draws heavily on the American philosophy and practice (this could be my limited perspective showing, but I think the term is probably used most frequently in this context as it is). I've attempted to add some mentions of Maoist theories and the Soviet commissars, but would really appreciate any input from editors who can contribute more material on theories of civilian control in other countries. — MC MasterChef :: Leave a tip — 09:22, 1 November 2005 (UTC)[reply]
  • Coeducation Brief discussion of history in U.S. only, and some lists. Needs internationalization in any case, and might the subject of women's education in Muslim and developing countries be appropriate here?
  • Columbus Day - suggests that Columbus Day has only ever been celebrated in the United States, and that opposition to the concept is limited to the United States - Now mentions similar holidays in several other countries, especially in Latin America, but none in Canada, although very few people in the latter celebrates the holiday. Examples of opposition from US and US Virgin Islands only.
  • Crenellation As if the concept is only relevant in medieval western European architecture. Lacks a global point of view, although it mentions the Great Wall of China (at the very least, Islamic architecture should be added). See also its talk.
  • Cronyism - only gives examples from the Bush presidency, where politicians all round the world hire their mates for the best jobs.
  • Death Legal definition section should be expanded.
  • Dinner Focuses on North America and the U.K.
  • Editorial cartoon Has only examples from the United States and Canada from the past supporting the war effort. Should need current editorial cartoons from other countries regarding other issues.
  • Famine Focuses mostly on the European experience, with fairly limited discussion of the modern phenomenon.
  • Freedom of speech Developed World examples only. Short paragraphs on the situation in India, in Asia in general and in Africa. Much potential for expansion.
  • Gang Deals almost exclusively with the U.S.
  • Ghosting (identity theft) The characterization deals with the U.S. as if understood, the rest is not much better.
  • Grade retention Most examples and statistics are from the United States, with a little from Canada, and much less for other countries
  • Grazing rights - mostly U.S. and a little Brit. Needs expansion for the many other countries that have domesticated grazing animals
  • Harp, Lyre, Flute, Drum and Musical Notation are all eurocentric. Nannus 18:18, 8 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
  • Height restriction laws Has only examples from US, Europe, and Bali.
  • Homeschooling Much of the article deals with homeschooling in the United States, especially with the statistics.
  • Homework History section only deals with the United States.
  • Illegal immigrant Only U.S. references. (Although the French Wikipedia's Sans-papiers article does not seem to have that much to add, it might at least provide a starting point for a European perspective. However, this article needs much more than that.)
  • Internationalization Anything but. Mentions internationalization only in one direction – from the US to other languages/cultures.
  • Category:Inventions The only inventions-by-nationality categories we have are for English-speaking nations: thus there's Category:Australian inventions but no Category:German inventions, even though we have a huge number of Category:German inventors each of whom presumably invented something notable. It's tempting to suppose that only nationalists tag articles with invention-by-nationality. —Blotwell 22:10, 4 May 2006 (UTC)[reply]
  • Journalism scandals A long list of examples, all but one or two from the U.S.
  • Labor law Limited to U.S. and U.K. mostly, misses the fact that there are international labor standards.
  • Labor union/Trade Union Some general history, but country-specific information for U.S., UK and Sweden only (excluding half a sentence mentioning China in the introduction).
  • Landmine. Almost entirely about the mines themselves and the countries that make and remove them. Countries plagued by mines are mentioned only in passing.
  • Lawyer/Solicitor Lead has U.S. perspective, only deals with the U.S., UK and Poland.
  • Locomotive and the related Electric locomotive and Diesel locomotive. Articles need added material on European history and usage, without Euro-biased suppression of North American experience. (This problem affects almost every article about rail technology, though most commonly it's the North American side that's missing.)
  • Manga, specifically the International Influences section, which is mostly American with a bit of Europe. ColourBurst 04:47, 16 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
  • Market town You wouldn't know that trade existed outside of Europe.
  • Marriage too much bias on s.s. marriage- western countries are minority against china, india, japan and third world/south america. article "s.s. marriage already exists". people may consider it "annoying information", just looking for man/woman marriage information. wikipedia is not a "political platform".
  • Media bias Mainly concerns itself with the U.S. liberal vs. conservative bias discussion.
  • Modesty - passes beyond systemic bias into outright chauvinism: modesty norms outside the industrialized Western world are only discussed (and then only briefly) in comparison and contrast to the average Western norm. Even that norm is generalized and ignores real variations between countries, regions, and ethnicities. Discussions of religious and cultural norms are no longer based on mere comparison to the average Western norm. However, still biased heavily in its general discussion of modesty toward generally accepted Western norms. Still needs work.
  • Music genre only US/West, doesn't even mention that there is music in Africa, or that people who are not Western have music at all. More discussion about "honky tonk" than about entire continents!

N-Z

  • Nudity, especially Various modern-era attitudes has only Western perspectives, plus a short sentence on Islam, and a bit on Japan, but nothing from Central/South America, Africa, or most of Asia.
  • Nursery rhyme solely deals with songs sung to children from a French and English perspective, and 1 sentence on indigenous cultures. Nothing from the rest of the world.
  • One-way traffic Sounds as if one-way traffic is only used in Lima, Peru and Europe.
  • Parking lot Seems as if parking lot legislation only exists in the United Kingdom and the United States.
  • Physician Generally lacking, as it currently deals mainly with training, but only covers the U.S., the UK and France.
  • Plastic Surgery has a section on cosmetic surgery which deals entirely with regulatory issues in the US
  • Police Mostly U.S. and UK (for historic reasons) references. Nothing on the role of the police force in neither democratic nor oppressive developing countries.
  • Proof coinage Article reads like the world has only one country (guess which one).
  • Public relations Almost exclusively uses U.S. examples and figures.
  • Public transport, vitally important throughout the developing world but the details focus on the decision to implement mass transit in industrialized countries
  • Rape Western perspective. Discusses the legal definitions of the U.S. and the UK only. Apart from brief mentions of the social consequences of rape in "societies with strong sexual customs and taboos", and rape as a means of torturing detainees in some countries, the rest of the article deals with the U.S. situation. No mention of the practice of rape as a war crime.
  • Royal Burial Ground focuses on a burial ground used by a royal family shared amongst the Commonwealth realms, yet focuses only on the United Kingdom.
  • Rubbing alcohol Laws and uses are only mentioned in UK and US contexts Johnny Au 17:22, 19 September 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Sandpit Mostly general, but lack details about its use in playgrounds outside North America; before my edit, it was US only. Johnny Au 03:09, 31 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Secondary Education The "in various countries" section almost entirely excludes Africa.
  • Social promotion Most examples and perspectives come from the United States with little from Canada and none elsewhere
  • Special needs consists of (a) American general view (b) American legal minutiae
  • State of Emergency only deals with the U.S.A. Still deals mainly with the U.S., although info on other Western democracies have been added. Very little on ongoing SoEs in e.g. Egypt and Syria.
  • Student activism and Youth activism Deals with the U.S. only. Nothing is said about the leading role students often take in protesting against oppressive societies, as in Czechoslovakia in 1968 (see Jan Palach), Myanmar (esp. 1988), China (Tiananmen Square protests of 1989), Iran (Iran student protests, July 1999), Serbia during Milosevic (see Otpor) and Indonesia (History of Indonesia). Also, the student protests of 1968 in places like Paris (May 1968) and Mexico City (Tlatelolco massacre) should also be mentioned.
    • I've reworked this page to give it a more international scope - US-specific stuff is in its own section now, and I've added a skeletal Indonesia section. More to do - the above is a great (inspiring!) list of places where student activists have (usually) made changes. - Cdc 20:10, 27 Nov 2004 (UTC)
      • I've added a small bit on France. The May 1968 page is extremely thorough so all we need here is a brief overview to show the context of it in student activist history. Leyanese 17:35, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC)
  • Traffic congestion This article mainly focuses on traffic in the United States. It contains only a small mention of traffic in the UK.
  • Unemployment Focused on the U.S., with a lengthy discussion on the U.S. definition and little or no mention of unemployment in other parts of the world.
  • Warship Virtually all information is about Europe.--Cúchullain t/c 20:39, 8 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
  • Water resources "The problem: Human populations in some areas (e.g. southern California, Israel, and Florida) are growing from 1 to 3% per year, while fresh water supplies are remaining constant or shrinking." Ever heard of a place called Africa? This article hasn't.
    • I've re-written and re-focused this article. As it stands, there are no explicit geographical references - don't know if that'll make you guys happy or sad. In the process of further refining this article, I expect specific geographical references will be worked back in or linked to. Toiyabe 19:44, 5 May 2005 (UTC)[reply]
  • Wedding. Western perspective, although some four sentences are included on non-Western traditions.
  • Ancestor worship focusses on Chinese and East Asian practices, with nothing on Africa or Amerindians (do they have ancestor worship?) --Taejo 09:39, 24 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]

Islam, Muslims, and the Muslim World

See also: Wikipedia:WikiProject Islam, Wikipedia:List of missing Middle Eastern topics
See Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Islam#Theology-centrism?—iFaqeer (Talk to me!) 22:41, Mar 1, 2005 (UTC)

Requests for expansion

  • Al-islam.org Apparently a large & popular website & forum (most popular, according to Yahoo) regarding Shia Islam, but the article is severely a stub.
  • Shalash al-Iraqi - I started this article after reading about him on an Iraqi's blog, and after doing some research I was unable to find any information on him that wasn't from other bloggers. I ended up using these as references anyway, I know that's not the ideal Wikipedia standard, but the blogs seem to suggest that he's very notable in Iraq. Is there anyone who has read a print article about him or can translate better web sources from Arabic, perhaps? Also, I'd appreciate a message on my talk page if this article is nominated for deletion. --Grace 07:28, 13 November 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Requests for review

  • Sunbul Effendi - this article has been posted to VfD. I believe the topic is notable but there is an issue with transcription: apparently the correct spelling would be Sümbül Efendi (alternate Sünbül Efendi). Google returns 179 results but most of them not in English. There are also alternate spellings like Sümbül Efendi, Sünbül Efendi, Şeyh Sümbül, Sümbül Sinan, Sünbül Sinan etc.--AYArktos 22:09, 9 May 2005 (UTC)[reply]
  • Baha'i Faith--Currently the editing of this entry (and related entries) is dominated by Baha'is, who take the opportunity to downplay criticisms and in general slant their information in predictable directions. Please consider this a call for non-Baha'i editors to come have a look at the site, and help ensure balance. Thank you. Dawud 10:44, 3 December 2005 (UTC)[reply]


Evangelical Protestantism

  • Carlton Pearson - Tulsa, Oklahoma-based African American preacher and theologian, long a protegé of Oral Roberts—also an advisor to Bush on faith-based initiatives, had a TV show, etc,—whose theology began to change in the late 1990s, when he decided that there is no Hell (or, more precisely, turned around to a rather existentialist view of Hell being something we make on earth, but not part of the afterlife). This eventually evolved into the Doctrine of Inclusion: that everyone is saved. As a result, his enormous Higher Dimensions [5] megachurch slowly collapsed, though, with his new theology, he again has a congregation numbering at least into the hundreds. Fascinating figure. Recent hour-long radio story about him on This American Life [6], but as of when I'm writing they haven't archived it to a permanent address. Founder of a Christian music festival that I believe is called Azuza, as well. -- Jmabel | Talk 19:24, 17 December 2005 (UTC)[reply]


Non-neoclassical economics

Probably the worst example of overclaiming what the status quo of experts really says about things is in economics. Many articles use definitions straight from neoclassical economics with little challenge from other theories. Though there has been work on this, it never seems to end. The article capitalism is not bad at balancing major theories and what they have to say but less-argued articles tend to be far less balanced and not give all major economic theories enough space. Where possible the claims of the economists who invent terms and metrics should be used, not the claims of those who promote them as silver bullets. Since every political party has its own theory of economics, and promotes its own policies as if they were such silver bullets, the dominant theories in rich countries have far too much space - see also Developed World bias above

Requests for expansion

Requests for review

Nature (biology, chemistry, physics and related)

Requested articles

  • gestation - This article is not an article, but a redirection to "mammalian pregnancy", whose title is disputed. There should be a separate article about gestation in general, that unlike pregnancy, discusses more about animal gestation. The word "gestation" itself is not well defined, because it is not explained which animals gestate, where the limit is between gestating and non-gestating animals, and the pragmatic, semantic and connotational difference between the words "gestation" and "preganancy".

Requests for expansion

  • mating - This article is a stub and should discuss more about animal mating, apart from copulation, like the behavior of animals that court or of social animals that nurture their offspring in pairs.
  • snail - This article is underdeveloped and doesn't discuss in more detail the different taxons of snails. Also, there may be some inaccuracies.
  • tool - The section regarding tool use in animals, while having numerous references, doesn't say much besides that monkeys & other primates, ravens, and sea otters have been observed using tools. Could be expanded.
  • Chinese astronomy - 3000 years of history and until recently was a single sentence. Above all, something should be added about astronomy in China today, to counter any perception that Chinese science is only about the past. Please help counter the bias against nonwestern science in this and other history of science articles.

Requests for review

  • Electrical engineering - This article is currently focusing on the North American meaning of the term. European and Global use seems to indictate the seperation of the terms Electrical and Electronic into different fields.
  • sex - This article focuses too much on the human aspect of sex and does not discuss essential things about sex like genetics, biology, biological evolution and origin of sex, etc.
  • mammalian pregnancy - The word "pregnancy" instead of "gestation" in the title of the article is dubious.
  • copulation
  • sexual intercourse
  • sexual reproduction

Perspective biases

Countering systemic bias open tasks

Soviet history

Many articles about the Soviet Union rely on information from anti-Soviet sources. Both pro- and anti-Soviet sources can be greatly biased. Where possible, cite the sources used, and try to find balance. GRuban 14:50, 1 March 2006 (UTC) (greatly condensing Paranoid 17:00, 17 July 2005 (UTC))[reply]

  • Please review Axis powers of World War II where Soviet Union is shown as an ally of Nazi Germany, while Spain even not shown as a Nazi collaborator state.--Certh 09:43, 20 February 2007 (UTC)[reply]
    • Um, did you read the article at all? It mentions that the Soviet Union was at one time an ally of Germany (which it was), but of course goes on to say how that changed after Operation Barabarosa. And there is a section discussion Spain's (and Portugal's) collaboration with Germany. I see no systemic bias in that article... --JerryOrr 12:26, 20 February 2007 (UTC)[reply]

People with disabilities; disability studies

I think most Wikipedians do not consider themselves people with disabilities. Therefore, things such as the sociology, history, psychology, language, etc of disabilities do not get covered in too much detail. We do have a very nice, somewhat long List of disability rights activists, but a lot of the artilces are redlinks. Some of the articles that are not redlinks go to articles about people other than the ones mentioned on the page, and need to be disambiguated; a few other are pages of politicians, whose pages need to be checked for mention in their involvement for disability rights. Also, the vast majority of people on the list, if not all of them, are from the Western world.

I suggest taking a peek at the history of Ed Roberts. There's an Ed Roberts who maufactured the Altair 8800 and an Ed Roberts who was the first disability rights activist at a university, who basically started the movement from scratch. There was a long article about the computer-related Ed Roberts, and none about the activist, though what the activist did came first chronologically by a few years, and was also easy to look up.

When a user first introduced information about the activist Ed Roberts at the bottom of the existing Ed Roberts page, someone removed the content without explaining why. (I can't speculate as to the mindset of the person. Maybe he or she just didn't know it was common practice to have a few lines about a different guy with the same name on the same page, before creating a disambiguation page. Then again, I hope it wasn't an off-the-cuff judgment that the activist Ed Roberts wasn't important.) The person who added it back said something along the lines of, "If you Google 'Ed Roberts' the first three links are about my guy, not yours." I have since created a disambiguation page, and grew Ed Roberts (activist) from a stub. The latter was featured on Did You Know -- but might never had grown to fruition if the original response to the new content was the last, which it certainly might have been. --Jacquelyn Marie 12:46, 12 October 2005 (UTC)[reply]

(reads over) I didn't really give a concrete request, did I? I guess the most concrete one I could give would be a request to fill in redlinks on the list of disability rights activists page.
But what I'm really looking for are other people who are willing to make it a priority every time they are on Wikipedia to add a little content regarding people with disabilities. I'd make a WikiProject if I could find the support. --Jacquelyn Marie 12:53, 12 October 2005 (UTC)[reply]

Underrepresented occupations

*Pipefitter redirects to Plumber and pipefitting redirects to Plumbing - fixed but needs expansion --Bookgrrl 05:01, 9 December 2006 (UTC) *Steamfitter - no article - redirected to pipefitting since everything I found everywhere including the trades description lumped the two together --Bookgrrl 05:01, 9 December 2006 (UTC)[reply]

General comment: one reason many of these articles do not exist, or are still stubs is that potential contributors have no model for a successful article on a profession. If one of the more complete articles could be improved into a featured article, this might help Wikipedians in filling these needs. -- llywrch 17:29, 19 June 2006 (UTC)[reply]
I agree, are there any jobs that are FA status? Engineer, or Software writer maybe? Kevlar67 02:36, 21 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Women and non-English-speaking Scientists

Numerous notable women and non-US/English scientists have no entries in Wikipedia. Ways to help include

  • award-winning scientists - developing articles for women and non-US scientists on pages that list award winners. (See especially the List of prizes, medals, and awards for women in science and Category:Awards by country, although many scientific medals are not yet included in those categories
  • List of members of the National Academy of Sciences is important
  • Standardizing "family" information across male and female scientists; in many entries on male scientists, family is not mentioned or is mentioned only minimally; family information is sometimesm accorded more priority for women biographies. Preferred for any scientist is prioritizing scientific accomplishments in the body of the article, with a small paragraph at the end of the biography section for personal/family connections. There are lots of scientist couples, and this is a good way to work on those articles -- find a female scientist who is married to a male scientist, and make sure both have equivalent family information.
  • Uncredited scientific achievements should be credited in the appropriate articles, with links to the scientists. This helps avoid erasure of women.
  • Scientific "pedigrees" that include notable students or advisors should be added where appropriate. Generally advisors listed near the top with graduate and postdoc work. Notable students may be mentioned in a single paragraph about the lab and/or influences of the scientist. This helps avoid erasure of women.
  • Too many embarrassing omissions to list them all, but Ruth Benerito ... Cynthia Kenyon ... Susan Solomon ... Jean Machnamara ... Elizabeth Neufeld ... Anne Anastasi ... Isabella L. Karle ... Marjorie Lee Browne (African-American mathematician; one of the first Af-Am female math phds in US)
  • These scientists need to be fleshed out: Esther Lederberg
  • Be sure to add them to the appropriate lists of scientists (and that's also a good way to find redlinked scientists who should be included)

Merging overrepresented content

In addition to adding new content to underrepresented areas, we should also work on minimizing content in overrepresented ones. It is easy to generate a hundred 1k articles out of 3k of text, if you break it up poorly and repeat yourself for a long intro paragraph in each of a hundred stubs, rather than making a single, concise page including them all.

Subjects to watch for:

  • Star Wars characters and locales
  • Star Trek characters and locales
  • Tolkien-related characters and locales
  • any modern television show (one article per episode summary, per throwaway character) -- particularly American and Japanese cartoons
  • Any serialized media : comic strips, comic books, serial stories, 10-part novels. In each case, figure out what the right chunk-size is for the text...
  • slang or jargon (can be moved to wiktionary, or combined into topical pages with the history of that jargon type, not one page per term)
  • Rapid transit stations (should be combined into articles about individual rapid transit lines instead if the station is not notable)

These are all topics that should be in Wikipedia; and none of the existing content needs to be removed; but repeated content, and generation of hundreds of stubs rather than one or two good articles, is bad for readers, for categorizers, for quality-editors, and for the 'random article' feature.— Preceding unsigned comment added by Sj (talk • contribs)

Not really sure what this has to do with countering systemic bias... --JerryOrr 11:30, 8 May 2006 (UTC)[reply]
It is relevant to systemic bias - contributors' systemic bias leads to these short messy articles. It isn't really what this project focuses on, though, which is more to do with filling in neglected areas. See umpteen discussions about choosing a less misleading name if you're interested. --Cherry blossom tree 22:34, 8 May 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_Countering_systemic_bias/open_tasks&oldid=180861465"