Taishanese

This article is about the dialect. For the people, see Taishanese people.

Taishanese
台山话
Native to	China, overseas communities particularly in United States and Canada
Region	Sze Yup, the Pearl River Delta; historic Chinese communities in California and New York City, Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver
Language family	Sino-Tibetan Sinitic Chinese Yue Siyi Taishanese
Language codes
ISO 639-3	–
ISO 639-6	tisa
Glottolog	tois1237
Linguasphere	79-AAA-mbc

Taishanese
Simplified Chinese	台山话
Traditional Chinese	臺山話
Transcriptions Standard Mandarin Hanyu Pinyin Táishān huà Yue: Cantonese Yale Romanization Tòihsāan wá Jyutping toi4 saan1 waa2 other Yue Taishanese hoi˧ san˨ va˧˨˥

Taishanese (Chinese: 台山话; pinyin: Táishān huà; Jyutping: toi4 saan1 waa2), alternatively romanized in Cantonese as Toishanese or Toisanese, in local dialect as Hoisanese or Hoisan-wa, is a Yue Chinese dialect native to Taishan, Guangdong. Although related, Taishanese has little mutual intelligibility with Cantonese. Taishanese is also spoken throughout Sze Yup (or Siyi in the pinyin romanization of Standard Mandarin Chinese), located on the western fringe of the Pearl River Delta in Guangdong China. In the late 19th century and early 20th century, most of the Chinese emigration to North America originated from Sze Yup (which includes Taishan). Thus, up to the mid-20th century, Taishanese was the dominant variety of the Chinese language spoken in Chinatowns in Canada and the United States. It was formerly the lingua franca of the overseas Chinese residing in the United States.

Names

The earliest linguistic studies refer to the dialect of Llin-nen or Xinning (traditional Chinese: 新寧; simplified Chinese: 新宁). Xinning was renamed Taishan in 1914, and linguistic literature has since generally referred to the local dialect as the Taishan dialect, a term based on the pinyin romanization of Standard Mandarin Chinese pronunciation. Alternative names have also been used. The term Toishan is a convention used by the United States Postal Service, the Defense Language Institute and the 2000 United States Census. The terms Toishan, Toisan, and Toisaan are all based on Cantonese pronunciation and are also frequently found in linguistic and non-linguistic literature. Hoisan is a term based on the local pronunciation, although it is not generally used in published literature.

These terms have also been anglicized with the suffix -ese: Taishanese, Toishanese, and Toisanese. Of the previous three terms, Taishanese is most commonly used in academic literature, to about the same extent as the term Taishan dialect. The terms Hoisanese and Hoisan-wa do appear in print literature, although they are used more on the internet.

Another term used is Sìyì (Sze Yup or Seiyap in Cantonese romanization; Chinese: 四邑; lit. 'four counties'). Sìyì or Sze Yup refers to a previous administrative division in the Pearl River Delta consisting of the four counties of Taishan, Kaiping, Enping and Xinhui. In 1983, a fifth county (Heshan) was added to the Jiangmen prefecture; so whereas the term Sìyì has become an anachronism, the older term Sze Yup remains in current use in overseas Chinese communities where it is their ancestral home. The term Wǔyì (Chinese: 五邑), literally "five counties", refers to the modern administrative region, but this term is not used to refer to Taishanese.

History

Taishanese originates from the Taishan region, where it is spoken. Taishanese can also be seen as a group of very closely related, mutually intelligible dialects spoken in the various towns and villages in and around Siyi (the four counties of Toishan, Hoiping, Yanping, Sunwui, transcribed from Cantonese; the names "Taishan, Kaiping, Enping and Xinhui", as above, are romanized from Standard Mandarin using Pinyin).

A vast number of Taishanese immigrants journeyed worldwide through the Taishan diaspora. The Taishan region was a major source of Chinese immigrants through continental Americas from the late-19th to mid-20th centuries. Taishanese was the predominant dialect spoken by the 19th-century Chinese builders of railroads in North America. Approximately 1.3 million people are estimated to have origins in Taishan. Prior to the signing of the Immigration and Naturalization Act of 1965, which allowed new waves of Chinese immigrants, Taishanese was the dominant dialect spoken in Chinatowns across North America.

As of 2015 Taishanese is still spoken in many Chinatowns throughout North America, including those of San Francisco, Oakland, Los Angeles, New York City, Boston, Vancouver, Toronto, Chicago, and Montreal by older generations of Chinese immigrants and their children, but is today being supplanted by mainstream Cantonese and increasingly by Mandarin in both older and newer Chinese communities alike, across the continent.

Relationship with Cantonese

Taishanese is a dialect of the Yue branch of Chinese, which also includes Cantonese. However, due to ambiguities in the meaning of "Cantonese" in the English language, as it can refer to both the greater Yue dialect group or its prestige standard (Standard Cantonese), "Taishanese" and "Cantonese" are commonly used in mutually exclusive contexts, i.e. Taishanese is treated separately from "Cantonese". Despite the closeness of the two, they are hardly mutually intelligible.

The phonology of Taishanese bears a lot of resemblance to Cantonese, since both of them are part of the same Yue branch. Like other Yue dialects, such as the Goulou dialects, Taishanese pronunciation and vocabulary may sometimes differ greatly from Cantonese. Although Taishan stands only 60 miles (100 km) from the city of Guangzhou, they are separated by numerous rivers, and the dialect of Taishan is among the most linguistically distant Yue dialects from the Guangzhou dialect.

Standard Cantonese functions as a lingua franca in Guangdong province, and speakers of other Chinese varieties (such as Chaozhou, Minnan, Hakka) living in Guangdong may also speak Cantonese. On the other hand, Standard Mandarin Chinese is the standard language of the People's Republic of China and the only legally allowed medium for teaching in schools throughout most of the country (except in minority areas), so residents of Taishan speak Mandarin as well. Although the Chinese government has been making great efforts to popularize Mandarin by administrative means, most Taishan residents do not speak Mandarin in their daily lives, but treat it as a second language, with Cantonese being the lingua franca of their region.

Phonology

Initial consonants

There are 19 to 23 initials consonants (or onsets) in Taishanese, which is shown in the chart below in IPA:

		Labial	Dental/ Alveolar		Palatal		Velar	Glottal
			plain	sibilant		plain
Nasal		m1	n1				ŋ1
Stop	prenasal	ᵐb1	ⁿd1				ᵑɡ1
	plain	p	t	t͡s2	t͡ɕ2		k	ʔ
	aspirated	pʰ	tʰ	t͡sʰ2	t͡ɕʰ2		kʰ
Fricative	voiceless	f	ɬ	s2	ɕ2			h
	voiced	v			ʒ3
Approximant			l			j3,4	w5

1. The respective nasal onsets (/m/, /n/, and /ŋ/) are allophones of the pre-nasalized voiced stop onsets (/ᵐb/, /ⁿd/, and /ᵑɡ/). The velar nasal (ŋ) sound occurs in both syllable initial and syllable final positions. There is a tendency toward denasalization for initial /ŋ/ as in 耳 /ŋi/ [ŋɡi] ‘ear’, 飲/饮 /ŋim/ [ŋɡim] ‘to drink’，魚 /ŋuy/ [ŋɡui] ‘fish’ and 月 /ŋut/ [ŋɡut] ‘moon’. In words like 牙 /ŋa/ ‘tooth’ and 我 /ŋoy/ ‘I; me’, denasalization does not seem to take place. In syllable final position following the rounded vowel [o], /ŋ/ is usually modified by lip-rounding. Examples are: 東 /uŋ/ ‘east’ and 紅 /huŋ/ ‘red’.
2. The palatal sibilants (/t͡ɕ/, /t͡ɕʰ/, and /ɕ/) are allophones of the respective alveolar sibilants (/t͡s/, /t͡sʰ/, and /s/) when the first vowel of the final consonant is high (/i/ and /u/).
3. The palatal approximant (/j/) is an allophone of the voiced fricative sibilant initial (/ʒ/).
4. The palatal approximant (/j/) can be a semivowel of the vowel /i/ when used as a glide.
5. The labial-velar approximant (/w/) can be a semivowel of the vowel /u/ when used as a glide.

Vowels

There are about seven different vowels in Taishanese:

	Front	Central	Back
Close	/i/1		/u/2
Close-Mid	/e/	/ə/3
Open-Mid	/ɛ/		/ɔ/
Open	/a/

1. The closed front vowel (/i/) can be a palatal approximant ([j]) as a semivowel.
2. The closed back vowel (/u/) can be a labial-velar approximant ([w]) as a semivowel.
3. The rounding of the schwa /ə/ is variable.

Final consonants

The final consonant (or rime) occurs after the initial sound, which consists of a medial, a nucleus, and a coda. There are three medial (or glides) in Taishanese that occur after the initial sound: null or no medial, /i/, or /u/. There are five main vowels after the medial: /a/, /e/, /i/, /u/, and null or no vowel. There are nine main codas at the end of the final: null or no coda, /i/, /u/, /m/, /n/, /ŋ/, /p/, /t/, and /k/.

Nucleus		-a-			-e-	-ɵ~ə-	-i-	-u-	-∅-
Medial		∅-	i-	u-	∅-	∅	∅-	∅-	∅-
Coda	-∅	[a]	[iɛ]	[uɔ]			[i]	[u]
	-i	[ai]		[uɔi]	[ei]			[ui]
	-u	[au]	[iau]		[eu]		[iu]
	-m	[am]	[iam]		[em]		[im]		[m]
	-n	[an]		[uɔn]	[en]		[in]	[un]
	-ŋ	[aŋ]	[iaŋ]	[ɔŋ]		[ɵŋ] ~ [əŋ]
	-p	[ap]	[iap]		[ep]		[ip]
	-t	[at]		[uɔt]	[et]	[ɵt] ~ [ət]	[it]	[ut]
	-k	[ak]	[iak]	[ɔk]		[ɵk] ~ [ək]

Tones

Taishanese is tonal. There are five contrastive lexical tones: high, mid, low, mid falling, and low falling. In at least one Taishanese dialect, the two falling tones have merged into a low falling tone. There is no tone sandhi.

Tone	Tone contour	Example	Changed tone	Chao Number	Jyutping tone number
high (yin shang)	˥ (55)	hau˥ 口 (mouth)	(none)	-	2
mid (yin ping)	˧ (33)	hau˧ 偷 (to steal)	mid rising	˧˥ (35)	1
low (yang ping)	˨ or ˩ (22 or 11)	hau˨ 頭 (head)	low rising	˨˥ (25)	4
mid falling	˧˩ (31)	hau˧˩ 皓 (bright)	mid dipping	˧˨˥ (325)	6
low falling (yang shang)	˨˩ (21)	hau˨˩ 厚 (thick)	low dipping	˨˩˥ (215)	5

Taishanese has four changed tones: mid rising, low rising, mid dipping and low dipping. These tones are called changed tones because they are the product of morphological processes (e.g. pluralization of pronouns) on four of the lexical tones. These tones have been analyzed as the addition of a high floating tone to the end of the mid, low, mid falling and low falling tones. The high endpoint of the changed tone often reaches an even higher pitch than the level high tone; this fact has led to the proposal of an expanded number of pitch levels for Taishanese tones. The changed tone can change the meaning of a word, and this distinguishes the changed tones from tone sandhi, which does not change a word's meaning. An example of a changed tone contrast is 刷 /tʃat˧/ (to brush) and 刷 /tʃat˨˩˥/ (a brush).

Tone name		Level píng 平	Rising shǎng 上	Departing qù 去	Entering rù 入
Upper yīn 陰	高	˧ (33)	˥ (55)	˧ (33)	˥ (5)
	低				˧ (3)
Lower yáng 陽	高	˨ or ˩ (22 or 11)	˨˩ (21)	˧˨ or ˧˩ (32 or 31)	˧˨ or ˧˩ (32 or 31)
	低				˨˩ (21)

Writing system

The writing system is Chinese. Historically, the common written language of Classical Literary Chinese united and facilitated cross-dialect exchange in dynastic China, as opposed to the spoken dialects which were too different to be mutually intelligible. In the 20th century, standard written Chinese, based on Mandarin, was codified as the new written standard. As Taishanese is primarily used in speech, characters needed specifically for writing Taishanese are not standardized and may vary. Commonly seen alternatives are shown below.

The sound represented by the IPA symbol ⟨ɬ⟩ (the voiceless alveolar lateral fricative) is particularly challenging, as it has no standard romanization. The digraph "lh" used above to represent this sound is used in Totonac, Chickasaw and Choctaw, which are among several written representations in the languages that include the sound. The alternative "hl" is used in Xhosa and Zulu, while "ll" is used in Welsh. Other written forms occur as well.

The following chart compares the personal pronouns among Taishanese, Cantonese, and Mandarin. In Taishanese, the plural forms of the pronouns are formed by changing the tone, whereas in Cantonese and Mandarin, a plural marker (地/哋/等 dei6 and 们/們 men, respectively) is added.

	Singular			Plural
	Taishanese	Standard Cantonese	Mandarin	Taishanese	Standard Cantonese	Mandarin
1st person	我 ngöi [ŋɔɪ˧] 我 ngöi [ŋɔɪ˧]	我 ngo5 我 ngo5	我 wǒ 我 wǒ	哦/偔/呆 ngo̖i [ŋɔɪ˨˩] 哦/偔/呆 ngo̖i [ŋɔɪ˨˩]	我 ngo5 哋 dei6 我 哋 ngo5 dei6	我们/我們 wǒmen 我们/我們 wǒmen
2nd person	你 nï [nɪ˧] 你 nï [nɪ˧]	你 nei5 你 nei5	你 nǐ 你 nǐ	偌/逽/聶 nie̖k [nɪɛk˨˩] 偌/逽/聶 nie̖k [nɪɛk˨˩]	你 nei5 哋 dei6 你 哋 nei5 dei6	你们/你們 nǐmen 你们/你們 nǐmen
3rd person	佢 küi [kʰuɪ˧] 佢 küi [kʰuɪ˧]	佢 keoi5 佢 keoi5	他 tā 他 tā	𠳞/佉/劇 kie̖k [kʰɪɛk˨˩] 𠳞/佉/劇 kie̖k [kʰɪɛk˨˩]	佢 keoi5 哋 dei6 佢 哋 keoi5 dei6	他们/他們 tāmen 他们/他們 tāmen

See also

• Varieties of Chinese
• Cantonese culture

References

• Anderson, Stephen R. (1978), "Tone features", in Fromkin, Victoria A. (ed.), Tone: A Linguistic Survey, New York, NY: Academic Press
• Bauer, Robert S.; Benedict, Paul K. (1997), Modern Cantonese Phonology, Berlin: Walter de Gruyter
• Chao, Yuen-Ren (1951), "Taishan Yuliao", Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Philology (Academia Sinica), 23: 25–76
• Chen, Matthew Y. (2000), Tone Sandhi: Patterns Across Chinese Dialects, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press
• Cheng, Teresa M. (1973), "The Phonology of Taishan", Journal of Chinese Linguistics, 1 (2): 256–322
• Chung, L. A. (2007), "Chung: Chinese 'peasant' dialect redeemed", San Jose Mercury News, San Jose, CA
• Defense Language Institute (1964), Chinese-Cantonese (Toishan) Basic Course, Washington, DC: Defense Language Institute
• Don, Alexander (1882), "The Lin-nen variation of Chinese", China Review: 236–247
• Grimes, John A. (1996). A Concise Dictionary of Indian Philosophy: Sanskrit Terms Defined in English. State University of New York Press. ISBN 0791430677.
• Him, Kam Tak (1980), "Semantic-Tonal Processes in Cantonese, Taishanese, Bobai and Siamese", Journal of Chinese Linguistics, 8 (2): 205–240
• Hom, Marlon Kau (1983), "Some Cantonese Folksongs on the American Experience", Western Folklore, 42 (2), Western Folklore, Vol. 42, No. 2: 126–139, doi:10.2307/1499969, JSTOR 1499969
• Hom, Marlon Kau (1987), Songs of Gold Mountain: Cantonese Rhymes from San Francisco, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
• Hsu, Madeline Y. (2000), Dreaming of Gold, Dreaming of Home: Transnationalism and Migration between the United States and China, 1882-1943, Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press
• Ladefoged, Peter; Maddieson, Ian (1996), The Sounds of the World's Languages, Blackwell Publishing, p. 203, ISBN 0-631-19815-6
• Lee, Gina (1987), "A Study of Toishan F0", Ohio State University Working Papers in Linguistics, 36: 16–30
• Leung, Genevieve Yuek-Ling (2012), Hoisan-wa reclaimed: Chinese American language maintenance and language ideology in historical and contemporary sociolinguistic perspective, Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania, pp. 1–237 (Ph.D. Dissertation)
• Light, Timothy (1986), "Toishan Affixal Aspects", in McCoy, John; Light, Timothy (eds.), Contributions to Sino-Tibetan Studies, Leiden, Netherlands: Brill, pp. 415–425
• Ma, Laurence; Cartier, Carolyn L., eds. (2003), The Chinese Diaspora: Space, Place, Mobility, and Identity, Rowman & Littlefield, p. 57, ISBN 0-7425-1756-X
• McCoy, John (1966), Szeyap Data for a First Approximation of Proto-Cantonese, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University (Ph.D. Dissertation)
• Ramsey, S. Robert (1987), The Languages of China, Princeton University Press, pp. 23–104, ISBN 0-691-06694-9
• Pulleyblank, Edwin (1984), Middle Chinese: A Study in Historical Phonology, UBC Press, p. 31, ISBN 0-7748-0192-1
• Szeto, Cecilia (2000), "Testing intelligibility among Sinitic dialects" (PDF), Proceedings of ALS2K, the 2000 Conference of the Australian Linguistic Society, retrieved 2008-09-06
• Wong, Maurice Kuen-shing (1982), Tone Change in Cantonese, Champaign, IL: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
• Yang, Fenggang (1999), Chinese Christians in America: Conversion, Assimilation, and Adhesive Identities, Penn State Press, p. 39
• Yip, Moira (2002), Tone, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press
• Yiu, T'ung (1946), The T'ai-Shan Dialect, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University (Ph.D. Dissertation)
• Yu, Alan (2007), "Understanding near mergers: The case of morphological tone in Cantonese", Phonology, 24 (1): 187–214, doi:10.1017/S0952675707001157, S2CID 18090490
• Yue-Hashimoto 余, Anne O. 霭芹 (2005), The Dancun Dialect of Taishan 台山淡村方言研究, Language Information Sciences Research Centre, City University of Hong Kong, ISBN 962-442-279-6

Notes

External links

• Stephen Li. "Taishanese Language Resources". Retrieved 2015-01-05. Taishanese Resources Website
• Stephen Li. "Toisanese Chop Suey 台山话杂碎". Retrieved 2015-01-05. Taishanese Language Blog
• Aaron Lee. "Four Counties 四邑". Retrieved 2015-01-05. Taishanese Language Blog
• C.J. Chow. "Learn Taishanese (台山話)". Archived from the original on 2014-12-17. Retrieved 2015-01-05. You can download the Defense Language Institute's 'Chinese-Cantonese (Toishan) Basic Course' audio and text material here
• Chinese Character to Taishanese Lookup tool Archived 2016-10-19 at the Wayback Machine
• Gene M. Chin. "Hoisanva Sites" Archived 2019-11-09 at the Wayback Machine. Alphabetical Dictionary and Lessons.