Norman Podhoretz

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Norman Podhoretz
Born (1930-01-16) January 16, 1930 (age 89)
Brownsville, Brooklyn, New York City, New York, U.S.
OccupationAuthor, commentator
NationalityAmerican
EducationColumbia University (BA)
Jewish Theological Seminary of America (BA)
Clare College, Cambridge (BA, MA)
SubjectNeoconservatism, American conservatism, politics, anti-communism
Spouse
Midge Decter (m. 1956)
ChildrenJohn Podhoretz

Norman Podhoretz (/pɒdˈhɔːrɪts/; born January 16, 1930) is an American neoconservative pundit, who identifies his views as "paleo-neoconservative".[1] He is a writer for Commentary magazine.[2][3]

Early life[edit]

The son of Julius and Helen (Woliner) Podhoretz,[4] Jewish immigrants[5] from the Central European region of Galicia (then part of Poland, now Ukraine),[6] Podhoretz was born and raised in Brownsville, Brooklyn. Podhoretz's family was leftist, with his elder sister joining a socialist youth movement. He skipped two grades and attended the prestigious Boys High School in the borough's Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood, ultimately graduating third in his class in 1946; his classmates included the prominent Assyriologist William W. Hallo and advertising executive Carl Spielvogel. Following his admission to Harvard University and New York University with partial tuition scholarships, Podhoretz ultimately elected to attend Columbia University when he was granted a full Pulitzer Scholarship.[7]

In 1950, Podhoretz received his BA degree in English literature from Columbia, where he was mentored by Lionel Trilling. He concurrently earned a second bachelor's degree in Hebrew literature from the nearby Jewish Theological Seminary of America; although Podhoretz never intended to enter the rabbinate, his father (who only attended synagogue on the High Holidays) wanted to ensure that his son was nonetheless conversant in "the intellectual tradition of his people",[7] as "a nonobservant New World Jew who ... treasured the Hebraic tradition".[8]

After being awarded the Kellett Fellowship from Columbia and a Fulbright Scholarship, he later received a second BA in literature with first-class honors and an Oxbridge MA from Clare College, Cambridge, where he briefly pursued doctoral studies after rejecting a graduate fellowship from Harvard. He also served in the United States Army from 1953 to 1955 as a draftee assigned to the Army Security Agency.[9]

Career[edit]

Podhoretz served as Commentary magazine's Editor-in-Chief from 1960 (when he replaced Elliot E. Cohen) until his retirement in 1995. Podhoretz remains Commentary's Editor-at-Large. In 1963, he wrote the essay "My Negro Problem – And Ours", in which he described the oppression he felt from African-Americans as a child, and concluded by calling for a color-blind society, and advocated "the wholesale merging of the two races [as] the most desirable alternative for everyone concerned."[10]

From 1981 to 1987, Podhoretz was an adviser to the U.S. Information Agency. From 1995 to 2003, he was a senior fellow at the Hudson Institute. He was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom by George W. Bush in 2004. The award recognized Podhoretz's intellectual contributions as editor-in-chief of Commentary magazine and as a senior fellow at the Hudson Institute.[11]

Norman Podhoretz was one of the original signatories of the "Statement of Principles" of the Project for the New American Century founded in 1997.[12] That organization sent a letter to President Clinton in 1998 advocating the removal by force of Saddam Husein in Iraq.

Podhoretz received the Guardian of Zion Award from Bar-Ilan University on May 24, 2007.

He served as a senior foreign policy advisor to Rudy Giuliani in his 2008 presidential campaign.[13] The same year, he publicly advocated an American attack on Iran.[14]

Podhoretz's 2009 book Why Are Jews Liberals? questions why American Jews for decades have been dependable Democrats, often supporting the party by margins of better than two-to-one, even in years of Republican landslides.[15]

Personal life[edit]

Podhoretz is married to author Midge Decter,[16] and his children include syndicated columnist and current Commentary editor-in-chief John Podhoretz. Norman Podhoretz said in early 2019, of his large family and its relation to his political views: "[I]f [Trump] doesn’t win in 2020, I would despair of the future. I have 13 grandchildren and 12 great grandchildren, and they are hostages to fortune. So I don’t have the luxury of not caring what’s going to happen after I’m gone."[1]

Political views[edit]

Initially a staunch liberal, Podhoretz moved Commentary to the left editorially when he took over the magazine. However, he became increasingly critical of the New Left and gradually moved rightward as the 1960s wore on. By the 1970s, he was a leading member of the neoconservative movement.

American history[edit]

Podhoretz has downplayed the importance of American history to his political beliefs. When Gore Vidal was writing his play On the March to the Sea, based on General William Tecumseh Sherman's March to the Sea during the U.S. Civil War, Podhoretz asked him:

"Why are you writing a play about, of all things, the Civil War?" When Vidal explained that this was/is "the great, single tragic event that gives resonance to our Republic", Podhoretz replied, "To me, the Civil War is as remote and irrelevant as the War of the Roses".[17]

Iraq[edit]

In the leadup to the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq, Podhoretz argued strongly for military intervention, claiming that Saddam Hussein posed a direct threat to the United States.[18] After the 9/11 attack and more than a year before the start of the War in Iraq, Podhoretz wrote in February 2002 that "There is no doubt that Saddam already possesses large stores of chemical and biological weapons, and may ... be 'on the precipice of nuclear power.' ... Some urge that we ... concentrate on easier targets first. Others contend that the longer we wait, the more dangerous Saddam will grow. Yet whether or not Iraq becomes the second front in the war against terrorism, one thing is certain: there can be no victory in this war if it ends with Saddam Hussein still in power."[19] No such weapons were or have been found.

Iran[edit]

In 2007, Podhoretz argued that the United States should attack Iranian nuclear facilities. According to The Sunday Times, Podhoretz believes that "Iraq, Afghanistan and Iran are merely different fronts of the same long war."[20] Podhoretz describes diplomatic efforts with Iran as similar to appeasement of Nazi Germany prior to World War II. He also contends that the War on Terror is a war against Islamofascism, and constitutes World War IV (World War III having been the Cold War), and advocates the bombing of Iran to preempt Iranian acquisition of nuclear weapons.[21] His book on that subject, entitled World War IV: The Long Struggle Against Islamofascism, was published by Doubleday on September 11, 2007.[22][23]

In a 2007 column, Podhoretz explicitly stated his view that Iran should be attacked: "In short, the plain and brutal truth is that if Iran is to be prevented from developing a nuclear arsenal, there is no alternative to the actual use of military force—any more than there was an alternative to force if Hitler was to be stopped in 1938."[24]

Vietnam[edit]

In an editorial to The Wall Street Journal on the sixth anniversary of the September 11 attacks, Podhoretz contends that the retreat from Iraq should not be similar to the retreat from Vietnam. He argues that when the U.S. withdrew from Vietnam, it sacrificed its national honor.[25]

In 1982, James Fallows wrote a review of Podhoretz's book, Why We Were in Vietnam, for The New York Times, in which he accuses Podhoretz of "changing his views" and "self-righteousness" on the subject of Vietnam, noting that in 1971 Podhoretz wrote that he would "prefer just such an American defeat to a 'Vietnamization' of the war."[26]

A larger quote from Why We Were in Vietnam which was included in the review is as follows:

As one who has never believed that anything good would ever come for us or for the world from an unambiguous American defeat, I now find myself – and here is the main source of my own embarrassment in writing about Vietnam – unhappily moving to the side of those who would prefer just such an American defeat to a 'Vietnamization' of the war which calls for the indefinite and unlimited bombardment by American pilots in American planes of every country in that already devastated region.

Soviet Union[edit]

In the early 1980s, Podhoretz was extremely skeptical that fundamental reform was possible in the USSR, and sharply criticized those who argued that U.S. policy toward the Soviet Union should be one of détente. In his 1980 book The Present Danger, Podhoretz predicted that the United States was in danger of losing the Cold War and falling behind the Soviet Union as a global power.[27] Later he would express anger with President Ronald Reagan for "not establishing sufficiently strong policies toward the Soviets."[28]

George W. Bush[edit]

Podhoretz has praised Bush, calling him "a man who knows evil when he sees it and who has demonstrated an unfailingly courageous willingness to endure vilification and contumely in setting his face against it." He calls Bush the president who was "battered more mercilessly and with less justification than any other in living memory."[18][24]

Sarah Palin[edit]

In a 2010 Wall Street Journal opinion piece titled "In Defense of Sarah Palin," Podhoretz wrote, "I hereby declare that I would rather be ruled by the Tea Party than by the Democratic Party, and I would rather have Sarah Palin sitting in the Oval Office than Barack Obama."[29]

Donald Trump[edit]

Podhoretz says of the 2016 Republican nomination process: {{cquote|"I began to be bothered by the hatred that was building up against Trump from my soon to be new set of ex-friends. It really disgusted me. I just thought it had no objective correlative... They called them dishonorable, or opportunists, or cowards—and this was done by people like Bret Stephens, Bill Kristol, and various others. And I took offense at that. So that inclined me to what I then became: anti-anti-Trump. By the time he finally won the nomination, I was sliding into a pro-Trump position, which has grown stronger and more passionate as time has gone on.[1]

Podhoretz says his views however, have caused him to lose ex-friends who were anti-Trump, saying: "Well some of them have gone so far as to make me wonder whether they’ve lost their minds altogether."[1] Of Trump, he argues: "[T]he fact that Trump was elected is a kind of miracle. I now believe he’s an unworthy vessel chosen by God to save us from the evil on the Left... His virtues are the virtues of the street kids of Brooklyn. You don’t back away from a fight and you fight to win. That’s one of the things that the Americans who love him, love him for—that he’s willing to fight, not willing but eager to fight. And that’s the main virtue and all the rest stem from, as Klingenstein says, his love of America. I mean, Trump loves America."[1]

Immigration[edit]

Podhoretz says that he had formerly been unthinkingly pro-immigration "because I’m the child of immigrants. And I thought it was unseemly of me to oppose what not only had saved my life, but had given me the best life I think I could possibly have had". However, his views latterly changed: "In 1924, immigration virtually stopped and the rationale for the new policy was to give newcomers a chance to assimilate—which may or may not have been the main reason—but it probably worked. What has changed my mind about immigration now—even legal immigration—is that our culture has weakened to the point where it’s no longer attractive enough for people to want to assimilate to, and we don’t insist that they do assimilate... That was the culture of the prewar period. You certainly wanted your children to be Americans—real Americans."[1]

Books[edit]

  • 1963: Hannah Arendt on Eichmann: a study in the perversity of brilliance New York: American Jewish Committee
  • 1963: My Negro problem and ours New York: American Jewish Committee
  • 1964: Doings and Undoings; the fifties and after in American writing. New York, Farrar, Straus (collection of essays)
  • 1966: The Commentary reader; two decades of articles and stories, New York, Atheneum editor (collection of essays).
  • 1967: Making It New York, Random House (autobiography) ISBN 0-394-43449-8
  • 1967: Jewishness & the younger intellectuals; a symposium reprinted from Commentary, a journal of significant thought and opinion on Jewish affairs and contemporary issues New York: American Jewish Committee (introduction)
  • 1979: Breaking Ranks: A Political Memoir New York: Harper & Row,
  • 1980: The Present Danger: "Do We Have the Will to Reverse the Decline of American Power?" New York: Simon & Schuster, ISBN 0-671-41395-3
  • 1981: The new defenders of capitalism Washington, D.C. : Ethics and Public Policy Center
  • 1982: Why We Were in Vietnam New York : Simon & Schuster, (history and argument) ISBN 0-671-44578-2
  • 1982: Congressional policy: a guide to American foreign policy and national defense Washington, D.C. : National Center for Legislative Research
  • 1983: The present and future danger: thoughts on Soviet/American foreign policy Washington, D.C.: National Center for Legislative Research
  • 1984: State of world Jewry address, 1983 New York : 92nd Street Y,
  • 1986: Terrorism – Reagan's response Coral Gables, Florida : North-South Center, University of Miami, Working Paper, Soviet and East European Studies Program (transcript of a debate with William Maynes, Jiri Valenta)
  • 1986: The Bloody Crossroads: Where Literature and Politics Meet New York : Simon & Schuster, (collection of essays) ISBN 0-671-61891-1
  • 1989: Israel, a lamentation from the future Dollard-des-Ormeaux, Quebec; Dawn Pub. Co.,
  • 1999: Ex-Friends: Falling Out With Allen Ginsberg, Lionel & Diana Trilling, Lillian Hellman, Hannah Arendt, and Norman Mailer New York,: Free Press, (memoir) ISBN 1-893554-17-1
  • 2000: My Love Affair With America: The Cautionary Tale of a Cheerful Conservative New York: Free Press, (autobiography) ISBN 1-893554-41-4
  • 2002: The Prophets: Who They Were, What They Are New York: Free Press, (about the classical Hebrew prophets) ISBN 0-7432-1927-9
  • 2003: The Norman Podhoretz Reader: A Selection of His Writings from the 1950s through the 1990s, New York: Free Press, edited by Thomas L. Jeffers; foreword by Paul Johnson ISBN 0-7432-3661-0
  • 2005: The Bush doctrine: what the President said and what it means Washington, D.C.: The Heritage Foundation
  • 2007: World War IV: The Long Struggle Against Islamofascism New York: Doubleday, ISBN 0-385-52221-5
  • 2009: Why Are Jews Liberals? New York: Doubleday, ISBN 0-385-52919-8

See also[edit]

DodgerBlue flag waving.svg Conservatism portal

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d e f An Interview with Norman Podhoretz April 16, 2019, Claremont
  2. ^ Commentary Magazine
  3. ^ "US". The Independent. Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  4. ^ "Norman Podhoretz". www.nndb.com. Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  5. ^ Contemporary Literary Criticism | Norman Podhoretz
  6. ^ Jeffers, Thomas L. (2004). "Editor's note". The Norman Podhoretz Reader: A Selection of His Writings from the 1950s through the 1990s. By Norman Podhoretz. Thomas L. Jeffers (ed.). Free Press. p. 1. ISBN 978-0743236614.
  7. ^ a b Jeffers, Thomas L. (2010). Norman Podhoretz: A Biography. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521198141. p. 5-6.
  8. ^ Jeffers (2010), p. 13.
  9. ^ "Podhoretz, Norman" (profile). Section, "Résumé". Right Web. rightweb.irc-online.org. Retrieved March 31, 2018.
  10. ^ http://www.lukeford.net/Images/photos/out.pdf
  11. ^ White House Personnel Announcement, Office of the Press Secretary, June 18, 2004.
  12. ^ "Statement of Principles". February 5, 2005. Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  13. ^ Giuliani's War Cabinet The American Prospect, September 25, 2007
  14. ^ "His Toughness Problem – and Ours", by Ian Buruma
  15. ^ Norman Podhoretz, Jewish conservative, asks, 'Why are Jews liberals?'
  16. ^ "Decter, Podhoretz Receive Luce Award". blog.heritage.org. Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  17. ^ Pettifer, Ann (December 14, 2002) Zionism Unbound, CounterPunch
  18. ^ a b Podhoretz N., "In Praise of the Bush Doctrine," Commentary Magazine, Sept. 2002
  19. ^ Podhoretz N., "How to Win World War IV,", Commentary Magazine, February 2002
  20. ^ Baxter, Sarah. "Neocon godfather Normal Podhoretz tells Bush: bomb Iran." The Sunday Times. September 30, 2007
  21. ^ Podhoretz N., "The Case for Bombing Iran," The Wall Street Journal, May 30, 2007. Accessed May 30, 2007.
  22. ^ "World War IV". Doubleday. Retrieved June 14, 2019.
  23. ^ Buckley Jr., William F. (October 22, 2007). "World War IV?". National Review. 59 (19): 62. Retrieved June 14, 2019. (published online September 6, 2007)
  24. ^ a b Podhoretz, Norman (June 2007). "The Case for Bombing Iran". Commentary Magazine. Archived from the original on August 19, 2010. Retrieved May 3, 2019.
  25. ^ Podhoretz N., "America the Ugly" The Wall Street Journal, September 11, 2007. Accessed September 11, 2007.
  26. ^ Fallows, James "In Defense of an Offensive War" The New York Times, March 28, 1982. Accessed January 3, 2008.
  27. ^ Norman Podhoretz, The Present Danger, New York: Simon & Schuster, 1980.
  28. ^ "The Rise of Neoconservatism", The Virginia Quarterly Review, Spring, 1996
  29. ^ Podhoretz, Norman (March 30, 2010) "In Defense of Sarah Palin." The Wall Street Journal.

Further reading[edit]

  • Abrams, Nathan. Norman Podhoretz and Commentary magazine: The rise and fall of the neocons, Continuum, 2010.
  • Balint, Benjamin. Running Commentary: The Contentious Magazine That Transformed the Jewish Left Into the Neoconservative Right (PublicAffairs; 2010)
  • Bloom, Alexander. Prodigal Sons: The New York Intellectuals & Their World, Oxford University Press, 1986. ISBN 978-0-19-505177-3
  • Jeffers, Thomas L. Norman Podhoretz: A Biography (Cambridge University Press; 2010) 393 pages
  • Menand, Louis (May 1, 2017). "Op de stez : Norman Podhoretz's classic success story". The Critics. Books. The New Yorker. 93 (11): 63–69. (Online version is titled "The book that scandalized the New York intellectuals".)
  • Winchell, Mark Royden. Neoconservative criticism: Norman Podhoretz, Kenneth S. Lynn, and Joseph Epstein, Twayne Publishers, 1991. Twayne's United States authors series

Primary sources[edit]

  • "Norman Podhoretz" New York: American Jewish Committee, Oral History Library, Transcript of an interview conducted by Jill Levine, December 2, 1980 and Jan 8, July 22, 1981.

External links[edit]